BACKGROUND INTRODUCTION
The Albuquerque City Council has enacted four measures misleadingly labeled the Better Neighborhoods Package. The legislation was passed under the guise of cutting red tape to allow development projects. The Better Neighborhoods package consists of two ordinances and two memorials. The two ordinances make dramatic changes to the Neighborhood Association Recognition Ordinance and severely limit the rights of appeals to stop developments. The two memorials request the New Mexico Legislature to define who has standing and the right to appeal developments and mandates direct and costly appeals to the courts.
The most egregious of the four measures is O-26-61. This ordinance eliminates formal city recognition of neighborhood coalitions and eliminates automatic development notices to them. It eliminates the requirement for developers to act in good faith and to cooperate with the very neighborhoods they want to develop in. O-26-61 strips standing from neighborhood coalitions to appeal developments. It requires neighborhood associations to redraw boundaries, adding extensive appeal conditions. Loss of city recognition of neighborhood coalitions means loss of notification to individuals and neighborhoods that are likely to be harmed by any development. Thirteen neighborhood associations will now lose city recognition or will have to kick out their county neighbors as members.
Ordinance O-26-61 was introduced and moved forward within two weeks for a full council vote without a committee hearing and no community discussion. It passed on a 5-4 vote. Voting “yes” were Republican councilors Dan Lewis, Dan Champine and Renee Grout and Democrats Stephanie Telles and Tammy Fiebelkorn. Voting “no” were Democratic City Council President Klarissa Peña, Democratic councilors Joaquín Baca and Nichole Rogers and Republican Brook Bassan. Mayor Tim Keller signed O-26-61 into law, falsely arguing that neighborhood coalitions were legally representing neighborhood associations without their consent.
Republican Dan Lewis was the sponsor of the “Better Neighborhoods” package. At the time of introduction, Councilor Lewis said neighborhood coalitions in general are “undemocratic” as decision-making bodies. Lewis provided no evidence to support this false assertion. Lewis said O-26-61 “right-sizes” neighborhood representation by putting authority back with “the neighborhoods that are closest and have a direct stake.” Lewis said appeals often come after a development has spent years moving through the city process. Lewis assailed the Westside Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA), which is in his district, as one of the “worst offenders” revealing his true motivations. That neighborhood appeal was repeatedly denied but eventually won in State District Court.
MIKE VOORHEES GUEST OPINION COLUMN
Mike Voorhees, whose educational background includes degrees in geography and engineering, moved to Albuquerque in 1995 to help grow the aerospace sector. Since then, he has been involved in various community organizations and activities, including a Habitat for Humanity house build, open space trail repair, and advocacy for safety and education in hot air ballooning. In 2024, after exposing multiple improper actions of the City’s Planning Department, he was elected to the Executive Committee of the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA) as Member at Large, and subsequently elected Vice President of WSCONA. In 2004, he was presented the FBI Director’s Award for “Exceptional Service in the Public Interest” for his work protecting and improving the security posture of critical infrastructure in New Mexico against both natural and human-caused threats.
EDITOR’S DISCLAIMER: Mike Voorhees submitted the following guest column to be published as a public service announcement only with no compensation and no solicitations requested nor paid by him or West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations to publisher www.PeteDinelli.com.
Discrediting Dan Lewis And City Council’s Elimination Of City Recognition Of Neighborhood Coalitions; The Truth And Importance Of Neighborhood Coalitions And The Work of Westside Coalition of Neighborhood Associations
Now that voters across the nation have repudiated the unconstrained greed, corruption, and recklessness of the Developer In Chief—who’s disrespect of cultural heritage, historic treasures, and irreplaceable public lands has outraged people of all walks of life—it is time to repudiate the unconstrained greed, corruption, and recklessness of some of Albuquerque’s developers and any politicians who may be in their pocket.
ALBUQUERQUE DOES NOT HAVE HOUSING CRISIS BUT AN AFFORDABILITY CRISIS
Much has been written by corporate media, beholden to business interests, pushing a false narrative that Albuquerque, like so many cities, has a housing crisis. The actual crisis is one of affordability, but that story is seldom told as it is inconvenient to those pushing a consumerist and uncontrolled growth agenda.
Quite cleverly, the private-equity-fueled campaign goes something like this:
“The reason why housing is expensive is a lack of supply, and the reason why there is a lack of supply is due to complicated government regulations and red tape, foisted upon us by pesky environmentalists and community activists. If we can cut that red tape and eliminate the regulations, the housing industry will build a utopia of abundance for us all.”
While this explanation sounds plausible and superficial searches seem to support it, unfortunately, this story and its entire premise are not remotely true. Let’s look at the actual facts first.
Mayor Keller often quotes a figure that Albuquerque needs an additional 50,000 housing units right away. Sometimes he says 30,000 housing units. The origin of this claim is a poorly constructed study based upon unsupported assumptions of large population growth, covering a multi-county area. Yet as of this writing, the Albuquerque metro area has approximately 376,025 occupied housing units and 25,695 vacant housing units, which is a vacancy rate of roughly 6.5%. To put that in context, Albuquerque has approximately 3.3 to 3.4 vacant market-viable housing units for every unhoused person.
ALBUQUERQUE’S DECLING POPULATION
Rather than growing, the population of Albuquerque has been declining since 2020, dropping from a peak of 564,888 residents in 2020 down to an estimated 555,119 in 2026 (a decrease of roughly 1.71%). Albuquerque Public Schools just reported losing approximately 20,000 students over the past decade, leaving many schools operating significantly below their intended capacities.
Demographers are debating whether 2026 is the first year of a nationwide switch from population growth to decline, as the fertility rate remains below replacement coupled with draconian immigration purges. In fact five states have experienced population losses, led by Vermont (-0.29%), Hawaii (-0.15%), California (-0.02%), New Mexico, and West Virginia.
Some 6,791 new apartment units have been built in the metro area over the past ten years. Albuquerque has some 58,906 existing units as of the end of Q1 2026, with 619 units under construction. From 2020 to the present, the City has issued over 14,000 building permits for single family homes.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SHORTAGE
Albuquerque has plenty of housing. What is missing is affordable housing.
Since 2020, during a period in which the population has fallen and rental inventories have dramatically increased, rental prices in Albuquerque have risen by 40%. That cannot be attributed to simplistic supply and demand.
When developers get their way and environmental regulations are gutted, those developers don’t begin a spree of affordable housing projects. Instead, they push high-rent, multi-story projects wherever they can—regardless of whether those looming monoliths have access to parks, open space, groceries, transportation, adequate parking, or neighborhood scale businesses designed for a sustainable or walkable community.
The developers also push projects of other hard-to-audit businesses like massive self-storage complexes, gas stations coupled to convenience stores with liquor sales and Convertible Virtual Currency (CVC) Kiosks—also known as Crypto ATMs—and of course the ubiquitous car wash, which as the fictional TV show Breaking Bad showcased is an excellent opportunity for money laundering.
Perhaps it is merely a coincidence that according to the Suspicious Activity Reports data of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), the vast majority of suspected illicit financial activity in the real estate sector comes from property management companies, real estate investment firms, realty and brokerage companies, and real estate development companies.
Developers also seem to love building corporate franchised drive-through fast food restaurants without regard to impact on traffic flow or air quality, and which degrade the supposed pedestrian-friendly walkability the city claims to promote. The proliferation of fast-food chains is also displacing local family-owned restaurants which have been part of the unique fabric of Albuquerque for decades.
To help sell this great bait-and-switch, straw man villains were needed, and thus the relentless labeling of Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions as NIMBYs (Not In My Back Yard). If the people most engaged in promoting livable cities and establishing policies balancing the needs and desires of the community could be tarred with being obstructionists, then the interests of private equity could sweep aside regulations and rapidly buy up newly rezoned property for haphazard construction regardless of long term viability, because out-of-state hedge funds and speculators will flip these projects, extracting any value long before the blight and land price manipulation collapses the viability of the city itself.
THE SUCCESS STORIES OF WSCONA
So who are these NIMBY bogeymen? My city councilor, Dan Lewis, loves to hate WSCONA, the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations. So what has WSCONA been doing to attract Lewis’ opprobrium? Let’s take a look:
WSCONA is a collection of neighborhood associations (NAs), homeowner associations (HOAs), and other residents whose neighborhoods no longer have an NA or never had one to begin with. As such, it helps to keep its members up to date on the policies and goings on of the city, county, and state; invites law enforcement to give updates on its policing practices and crime statistics; invites elected officials and community leaders to present policy agendas and receive feedback; and advocates for the wise use of taxpayer funds to meet community needs.
WSCONA has been recognized by the City for over a decade, and during that time it would receive notices of proposed development projects within or near its boundaries, and would pass these notices to its members, including HOAs which otherwise receive no notification. WSCONA often attends meetings and hearings on proposed developments—especially when those developments don’t comply with the existing regulations that protect the livability of the neighborhoods and the community as a whole—and in those meetings WSCONA offers alternative suggestions on how to improve those development projects. On rare occasions, when a development falls so far outside of compliance with the city’s rules and regulations, or when the City fails to abide by its own laws in how it grants approval to such projects, WSCONA will undertake administrative or legal action to resolve the issue.
To give you an idea of the projects in which WSCONA has been involved, we have compiled a representative sample of projects for which we advocated, projects that we successfully influenced to be better than first proposed, and projects which we have stopped.
WSCONA has supported many neighborhoods in addressing concerns related to land use proposals. Much time and research have been spent reviewing development proposals to ensure they meet the Albuquerque Comprehensive Plan’s goals and policies, as well as zoning regulations. This work helps preserve Albuquerque’s unique landscapes and our quality of life. WSCONA does not get involved frivolously.
Following are major develops that WSCONA became involved with:
The Vista de la Luz Plaza: 2007-2008: WSCONA offered design improvement suggestions to the proposed strip mall which had no plans for any windows looking east to the Sandia mountains. By adding windows to the plan, it enabled the development to attract Jinja Bar & Restaurant Westside as a Tennent, allowing the restaurant to feature stunning views that otherwise would have been blocked. This business has been going strong ever since.
The Walmart proposed for Coors and Montano: 2011- 2013: WSCONA supported Taylor Ranch Neighborhood Association (TRNA) and surrounding neighborhoods’ efforts to oppose the Walmart, a large retail facility proposed for Coors and Montano, adjacent to the Bosque’s Rio Grande Valley State Park and Bosque School. It did not meet the Coors Corridor Sector development plan, the Goals and Policies of the Comp Plan, the Westside Strategic Plan, or the Big Box ordinance. As a result, a more appropriate shopping center was later approved that is more walkable for the surrounding community and provides a variety of businesses including a Sprouts, PetSmart, LaCumbre Brewing, Grassburger, etc…
Poole Property: 2018- 2021: Adjacent to the Rio Grande Bosque and Oxbow wetlands, the Poole property is another example of WSCONA supporting TRNA and surrounding neighborhoods in opposing a subdivision that did not adhere to the IDO’s protective zoning requirements. Development of this area would have created numerous problems for existing homeowners and had subdivision infrastructure plans that directly impacted the sensitive nature of the wetlands. Because of the Community’s involvement, this area was ultimately acquired as City Open Space after working with the applicants. The Poole property now provides needed protection for the Bosque, preserves fantastic views, and creates an opportunity for residents to enjoy a beautiful natural setting with abundant wildlife.
Saranam: 2020: WSCONA also joined TRNA’s support for Saranam, a two-year transitional living facility that helps families avoid homelessness and become sustainable after attending a rigorous 2 year education program to prepare them for an independent life.
La Cuentista Open Space: WSCONA joined with TRNA to advocate for the purchase of 60 acres of La Cuentista Open Space. This land buffers the Petroglyph escarpment and preserves the culturally important view shed, rock outcroppings, wildlife, and juniper forest within those boundaries, while providing recreational trails for nearby residents and visitors alike.
IDO amendment Update: WSCONA has been involved in numerous meetings and thousands of hours regarding the IDO amendment process. Since the IDO was enacted in 2017, there have been more than 700 amendments—which is an absurd number—and most of these amendments have been requested by developers to allow more generic construction without reflecting the local character, cultural heritage, or historic styles for which Albuquerque is known and which help attract tourists the world over. WSCONA has testified about why it is important to maintain these zoning protections that help make Albuquerque a unique place to live.
DEEP DIVE INTO COMPLICATED SAGA
Now let’s take a deep dive into one property at the center of multiple appeals—the vacant property on the southwest corner of Paseo del Norte and Kimmick, which can be seen as you drive west on Paseo as you crest the hill of the escarpment. This saga is long, and so patience is necessary to even read a brief summary:
Before the IDO, the entire parcel was zoned to accommodate low level neighborhood scale businesses while preserving the views and cultural heritage near Petroglyph National Monument. Hundreds of families bought homes in the adjacent neighborhoods with the expectation that the City would honor this commitment.
However, the first proposal the current developer tried to get approved for this property was an enormous three-story tall self storage facility that would have blocked views to and from Petroglyph National Monument and its volcanoes, obstructed views to the Jemez Mountains for neighborhoods to the south, and would have interfered with traditional cultural practices of 29 pueblos and tribes for whom the petroglyphs and volcanoes are sacred.
Several neighbors and I, along with the Santa Fe Village Neighborhood Association and WSCONA opposed the self storage proposal in a facilitated meeting. The developer ignored our concerns. We then opposed the self storage proposal in a Zoning Hearing Examiner (ZHE) hearing, and the ZHE ruled in our favor. The developer appealed to the Land Use Hearing Officer (LUHO) who remanded the issue back to the ZHE with instructions. The developer ignored the instructions and presented misleading information. The ZHE ordered an additional facilitated meeting, during which the developer would not budge. After several ZHE continuances, the developer finally agreed to withdraw the application.
Importantly, during this period the City was not requiring nor facilitating any outreach for the Pueblos and Tribes who have ties to this land dating back millennia.
Shortly after the self storage application saga began, the developer held a facilitated meeting to announce plans for a ten-building three-story tall apartment complex on the southern portion of the same property. From the start he insisted that this would be high end market rate luxury apartments, with zero units dedicated to affordable housing. We expressed disappointment at the lack of affordable housing, but we also informed him that the height of the planned buildings would violate the zoning ordinances and comprehensive plans. The developer ignored our concerns. We reached out to the Pueblos and Tribes, in addition to the residents in the nearby neighborhoods, to let them know what was being planned. The developer then proceeded to get his plan approved by the Development Review Board (DRB) which as a matter of law had no jurisdiction to do so.
The DRB used outdated and inaccurate maps to justify their approval, so I, along with WSCONA and the Pueblo of Laguna appealed to the LUHO, wherein the timing of the filing required us to work over the Thanksgiving weekend to meet the 15 day deadline. (Many of the these developer applications are submitted just before holidays when the timeline for any resulting appeals conflict with holidays when most people are busy with celebrations, and the developers often get away with gross violations as a result.) The LUHO ruled against us as did the City Council, so we appealed that case to district court. The district court improperly ruled against us, and so we appealed to the Court of Appeals, which found that the City had indeed violated its own rules, and therefore overturned the DRB approval and remanded the issue to the Environmental Planning Commission (EPC).
Shortly after the apartment complex approval by the DRB, the developer realized that the project they had proposed violated a view protection overlay zone. They therefore reached out to Councilor Lewis, who sponsored an amendment to the Integrated Development Ordinance (IDO) at the request of the developer that would limit how to apply the view protections for Petroglyph National Monument, in order to exempt the apartment complex from following the existing rules. We informed the City that such sponsorship by Lewis would require him to recuse himself in any proceedings on this matter. City staff recommended against Lewis’ amendment. The EPC voted against Lewis’ amendment. Nevertheless, Lewis revived the amendment in the LUPZ committee. He moved the issue and voted for it. In full council, he again moved and voted for it. At no time did he entertain our request for his recusal. Thus we appealed to district court, which ruled in our favor, finding that Lewis unlawfully prejudged the issue with bias in violation of his duty to act impartially, and therefore the enactment was reversed by the court and remanded to the City Council, with the stipulation that Councilor Lewis not be allowed to participate in the remand. The City appealed to the Court of Appeals, but the Court of Appeals upheld the ruling in favor of WSCONA.
While the above court actions proceeded, the developer continued to try and advance the project through multiple improper subdivisions that were approved by Development Hearing Officers (DHOs) who failed to even notify WSCONA that the hearings were taking place. It is hard to express opposition to something when the City keeps it a secret. As it turns out, one of the DHOs was actually in the employ of one of the property owners for the development in question at the time of his first ruling, but this fact was also kept secret by using the State’s LLC privacy rules.
While we waited for the Mandate of the Court from the first case overturning the DRB approval to make its way back to the City, the developer attempted to rush through an approval via the EPC which was predicated upon the illegal subdivision which was conducted by the DRB that had lacked jurisdiction in the first place. During that EPC hearing, City staff admitted under oath that the subdivision and related notice were invalid and inaccurate, and an appeal would likely prevail. The EPC was informed of the Court of Appeals ruling, but chose to ignore this, approving the Site Plan nonetheless. WSCONA was forced yet again to appeal to the LUHO, along with the Pueblos of Laguna and Santa Clara, however this time, because Councilor Lewis had convinced the City Council to enact punitive laws that year limiting the standing of Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions, it would be even more difficult, including a new requirement for obtaining dozens of petition signatures from neighbors over the holiday between Christmas and New Years.
Interestingly, in an unrelated case which involved even taller buildings that would have disrupted the view shed of the volcanoes of Petroglyph National Monument, Judge Barela Shepard ruled that the City had no authority under state law to limit the standing of anyone, including Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions.
So back to the apartments, the LUHO again ruled against us as did the City Council, with Councilor Lewis again failing to recuse himself. We have since joined the appeal to district court filed by the Pueblo of Laguna, where it lies today.
But wait, there is more. The developer switched plans from locating a neighborhood scale grocery store on the northeast corner of the property to a gas station with liquor sales. This would need a conditional use approval from the ZHE. Apparently the developer was hoping that such an approval would establish that the unlawful subdivision of the property was a fait accompli and could not be reversed, and that would sever the lot for the rest of the property, in effect doing in fact what Councilor Lewis’ amendment on the view protections was stopped from doing. So we have appealed that to the LUHO.
REPEAL LEWIS/CITY COUNCIL PUNITIVE LEGISLATION
As complicated and convoluted as this synopsis is, the full story and details are even more troubling. If you find the behavior of the City and the developer unacceptable, perhaps you will consider donating to our legal fund. We are unpaid volunteers fighting corruption and gross incompetence at every step. And since we have successfully appealed these issues, the City Council has enacted more punitive legislation, namely O-26-60 and O-26-61, of course sponsored by Councilor Dan Lewis. One of these would charge coalitions like WSCONA $1000 to appeal an improperly granted development approval, but only charge developers $300 if their project was denied. If you think this sounds unconstitutional, that is because it is.
What can be done about these unconstitutional ordinances? Two options come to mind. The first is yet another law suit, which would cost the plaintiff and the City thousands of dollars. The second option would be for the City Council to repeal them, saving taxpayer money and restoring the Constitutional rights of Burqueños. Repealing is the better option. If just one other councilor joined Councilors Rogers, Bassan, Baca, and Peña, repeal could be swift, and that councilor would rejoin the right side of history.
The issues we and other coalitions have opposed include policies that would make it harder for young families to buy a home of their own, would create a permanent rental class forced to pay ever more to hedge fund controlled landlords, and keep the people from having a say in whether we want data centers in our city. The City often ignores the need to ensure our community has enough water; it occasionally disregards concerns over rising heat and fire danger; and squanders the cultural heritage of our city that contributes to our economy—tourists are not interested in another city full of generic strip malls and drive throughs. If standing up for these values makes us NIMBYs, so be it, but we have never opposed actual affordable housing projects.
To learn more about WISCONA and its advocacy for sustainable and live able neighborhood hoods and our community please visit:
wsconanm.org
RESPECTFULLY,
Mike Voorhees
DINELLI COMMENTARY AND ANALYSIS
A POLITICALLY MOTIVATED AND VINDICTIVE DAN LEWIS
It is clear that the four city council actions sponsored by Dan Lewis were politically motivated. Lewis has an extensive history of tangling and disagreeing with the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA) who have often objected to many of his efforts on the city council and development projects that may affect their homes and neighborhoods.
City Councilor Dan Lewis is one of the longest serving City Councilors having been elected to three 4 year terms. During the last five years Dan Lewis has exhibited a pattern of downright hostility towards his own constituents who oppose or who disagree with his votes on policy and legislation. Lewis has a reputation during city council meetings of berating, insulting or ignoring members of the public who disagree with him. Lewis is known to be constantly on his phone or texting during city council public comments. Lewis is known to go out of his way to offend citizens by leaving meetings very early on not to return.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS SUBSIDIZED HOUSING
The term “affordable housing” is about as misleading as it gets. It is a term way too often used by elected officials and politicians to simply declare a crisis with inflated numbers that shows there is not enough housing that allows the poor or low-income people to rent or buy a home and call their own. Housing prices and rental costs never come down. The more appropriate term that should be used is “subsidized” housing where it’s clear what is needed is subsidized funding for those who cannot afford to buy outright or rent and need assistance.
The housing shortage is related to economics, the development community’s inability to keep up with supply and demand and the public’s inability to purchase housing or qualify for housing mortgage loans. The shortage of rental properties has resulted in dramatic increases in rents. It’s clear that the City of Albuquerque and the state of New Mexico are suffering from a shortage of housing, but that does not mean it is all affordable housing.
It is a false narrative that increasing density in established neighborhoods will somehow create affordable housing and allow for needed commercial development when it will not. Instead, it will lead to gentrification as investors buy up established neighborhoods or historical neighborhoods to develop into high end housing. Market forces will prevail and developers will build to make a profit and not build affordable housing. What is totally ignored with proposing to change zoning law is the millions, if not billions of dollars, that are already being spent and invested by the city and state to build and to address affordable housing.
The very real consequences of passage of O-26-61 are clear and are as follows:
- Thirteen neighborhood associations will either lose recognition or have to kick out their county neighbors as members.
- Loss of recognition equals the loss of notification to those individuals and neighborhoods that are likely to be harmed by the development.
- It removes the requirement for developers to act in good faith and to cooperate with the very neighborhoods they chose to develop.
It is clear that the city’s council’s enactment of the Dan Lewis sponsored Better Neighborhoods Package was to benefit the development, real estate and investment community to the determent of established neighborhoods. It will have a major impact eliminating the rights of neighborhood coalitions to challenge developments. When a new apartment complex or commercial development is proposed in neighborhoods that will have a detrimental impact on the neighborhood, especially historical or established neighborhoods, individual property owners often look to neighborhood coalitions to help appeal or challenge the projects because the individuals do not have the financial resources of their own to oppose developers.
Passage of the Better Neighborhoods package is an effort to deconstruct guardrails and protections. It marginalizes the voices of neighborhoods and city residents. Passage of the Better Neighborhoods package was a sellout by Keller and the Albuquerque City Council of the citizens of Albuquerque, property owners and neighborhood associations and coalitions in favor of the development community.
CITY COUNCIL REPEAL“BETTER NEIGHBORHOODS” PACKAGE
The four City Councilors who voted “NO” to enact O-26-61 were Democrat City Council President Klarissa Peña, Progressive Democrats Jaquin Baca and Nichole Rogers and Republican Brook Bassan. One or all 4 should take immediate steps to repeal O-26-61 and the “Better Neighborhoods” package by sponsoring and introducing a resolution or ordinance repealing the legislation and demanding public hearings before the City Council’s Land Use and Planning committee to allow the public sufficient time weigh in and to avoid the two week rush job that came with enactment of O-26-61.
Contact your City Councilor and tell them to repeal O-26-61 and protest the underhanded way it was enacted.
CITY COUNCIL CONTACT INFORMATION
CITY COUNCIL PHONE: (505) 768-3100
CITY COUNCILOR AND SUPPORT STAFF EMAILS
ipadilla@cabq.gov (Director of Council Services)
mmmontoya@cabq.gov (Council Clerk)