Political Editorial Cartoonist John Trever Celebrates 50 Years With Albuquerque Journal; Recalling Dinelli Published Trevor Editorial Cartoons; COMMENTARY: Political Editorial Cartoons Highest Form Of Protected Free Speech

According to an August 9, 2026 Albuquerque Journal article, Political Editorial Cartoonist John Trever has been employed by the Albuquerque Journal and is celebrating 50 years of producing political editorial cartoons for the paper. The article states in part:

“During that period, he has produced roughly 10,000 cartoons and won multiple local, regional and national awards. …  In 1980, Trever became syndicated, and his work was part of a package of cartoons that went out to more than 300 newspapers nationwide. At that time, nearly half of his cartoons were about national events and the rest local. John Trevor semiretired in 2010, and now produces roughly one local cartoon a week for the Albuquerque Journal.” 

“John Trevor uses a pen to produce his cartoons and not images produced [by artificial intelligence nor] a computer to create his images. … He then accompanies his cartoons with  a few pithy words, to make people chuckle and think and sometimes, not often, he acknowledges, see a different point of view. …  He still comes into the office to work on that week’s cartoon, sitting at his drawing desk next to a glass wall that looks out over the newsroom.” …

“Dan Herrera, whose career at the Albuquerque Journal spanned more than three decades, many of them serving on the paper’s Editorial Board in different capacities [said this about John Trevor]:

He’s especially good at covering New Mexico events. … When I was the editorial page editor, he was doing six cartoons a week, which just coming up with that many ideas is an incredible feat. But they all were spot on. …  John Trever is a national treasure, he really is. …  His cartoons are funny, they’re hard hitting, and he hits everybody equally. And, he’s a nice guy, too!”

The article went into detail about Trevor’s 50 years with the Journal where he highlighted numerous cartoons covering New Mexico politics.  You can read the quoted and relied upon Albuquerque Journal article that also contains a lengthy interview of John Trevor by former Journal editor Karen Moses here:

https://www.abqjournal.com/opinion/using-humor-to-make-a-point/3095075

On November 16, 2026, the Albuquerque Journal published a special report highlighting what the paper described as some of the best work of John Trevor over 50 years and publishing selected editorial cartoons covering the decades of the 1970’s, 1980’s, 1990’s, 2000’s, 2010’s and 2020’s. The link to review the editorial cartoons is here:

https://www.abqjournal.com/opinion/the-best-of-journal-cartoonist-john-trever/3152285

RECALLING TREVOR CARTOONS

The Albuquerque Journal’s celebration of John Trevor’s fifty year career with the paper reminded me that I was the subject of seven (7) Trevor cartoons when I served on the Albuquerque City Council from 1986 to 1989 and from 2001 to 2009 when I was a Deputy City Attorney and later when I ran for Mayor in 2013.

Below are the political cartoons where I was depicted with a narrative on each one:

“DINELLI THE MENACE”

The below Trevor cartoon depicts former Mayor Ken Shultz Spokesman Mike Santullo as an angry  pit bull trying to get to me but held back by a fence while I was intentionally provoking him through the fence with a stick and giving him the “raspberries” and me yelling “HATCHET MAN” , “NYAAHA, NYAAHA ”, “POLITCAL PIMP”, “BBLAAT”. The caption reads “Dear, dear, look at that vicious animal threatening the Dinelli boy! I tell you they should ban those pit bulls” as the couple drove by “Schult’z City Yard”.

I burst out laughing when I saw it the morning it was published. I called Trevor to ask him why I was depicted in overalls. Trever told me he dressed me like “Dennis the Menace” because of what I said and depicted Mayor Schultz’s spoke person Mike Santullo, a former radio talk show host known for his sharp political opinions, as a pit bull because of the aggressive way he reacted. Santullo had said that I “was suffering from politcal amnesia” on a position held by Mayor Schultz and he called into question my honesty and integrity. I responded to the accusations by  calling  him a “hatchet man” and a “politcal pimp” in charge of selling the Mayor. After reading my comments in the Journal, Mike Santullo fired off a profanity laced letter threatening to sue me and he gave it to the Journal and I responded saying I would be delighted to file a counter claim. Being a trial lawyer does have its advantages.

Over many years, Mike and I  mellowed out immensely and we became friendly to each other, but damn we sure did accomplish a lot back then despite our political differences and despite ourselves! Mike has since passed away as has Mayor Ken Schultz.

27629320_1724777527656591_2753120354171006632_o

“THE BLACK ROSE INCIDENT”

Below is another Trever cartoon published by the Journal when I was a city councilor. The “black rose incident” was when two Albuquerque Police Union officials went to Santa Fe during a legislative session and placed a “black rose” on the house chamber floor desk of then State Representative Cisco McSorley with a cartoon of a person with a knife in his back that had the caption “Thank you for all your support.” The police union was upset that the State Representative did not vote for a measure they wanted.

A “black rose”  symbolizes a death threat in organized crime circles. I was asked by the Albuquerque Journal what I thought about what the union officials did and I said the black rose and the cartoon were intimidation and the threat of an elected official that should not be tolerated. I also said I felt that the APD Union reps should be fired and that got me in trouble. When asked by the Journal if they were entitled to “due process” before being fired, I said yes, give them due process and then fire them. All hell broke loose and the cartoon was published ostensibly making the point that I had blown things up way out of proportion. Trevor’s editorial cartoon has me blowing up a “black rose hot air balloon” as I stood in front of City Hall with a person yelling at me from a city hall third floor window “A little early for the balloon fiesta, isn’t it?” .

27628914_1724783954322615_466044288878790561_o

“ALBUQUERQUE CHAINSAW MANICURE”

The below Trever cartoon was published when I was Chairman of the City Council Finance Committee. We were faced with making $10 million in cuts to a $450 million city budget. Today, annual city budgets are $1.2 Billion. Mayor Schultz was upset with me and the City Council for budget cuts and made it known in no uncertain terms. The cartoon has Mayor Schulz sitting in a barber chair wearing a smock with the words “SCHULTZ CITY BUDGET” emblazoned on it while his hair is being cut by a barber who  appears to be longtime City Councilor Pat Baca as the City Council and I was pictured sitting down on a stool and giving Mayor Schultz  a manicure and clipping his fingernails with Schultz crying out in tremendous pain yelling “OUCH!! NOT THAT! STOP IT! YOU’LL CRIPPLE ME! The caption reads “The Albuquerque Chainsaw Manicure”

27907994_1724785680989109_555685797457878990_o

“HARMONIC CONVERGENCE AT CITY HALL”

The below John Trever cartoon was published by the Journal in 1987 when I was on the City Council. The city council was having public hearings on the “Quality of Life” 10-year quarter cent tax.  The City Council decided to go ahead on its own without the Mayor to conduct a series of public hearings at venues throughout the city to solicit public input to decide upon major projects that were needed for a growing city. I was the sponsor or cosponsor of three out of four city council resolutions that  eventually became the quality of life tax. The ten year quality life tax resulted in the construction of the Balloon Museum, the Children’s Science Museum, the Botanic Gardens and the Aquarium as well as acquisition of critical open space in the Sandia Foothills to complete the Elena Gallegos open space area. The tax package also originally had funding for a performing arts center that was later voted down by the public. “The Harmonic Convergence” was the name given to one of the world’s first globally synchronized meditation events to coincide with the planets aligning in the solar system. (No joke). Pictured from left to right are City Councilor Steve Gallegos, Mayor Ken Schultz, City Councilor Fran Hill, myself and City Councilor Pat Baca, with all of us beating drums. We are chanting “Quality of Life … Quarter Cent, Quality of Life Quarter Cent, Ommm” and the caption reads “HARMONIC CONVERGENCE AT CITY HALL”.

27545508_1725067800960897_1628196091904880849_n

“WELL THERE GOES THE NEIGHBORHOOD”

This Trever cartoon was published when I was a city councilor sponsoring zoning regulations restricting pornography shops and theaters to only certain zones and away from schools. To the left is an XXX rated bookstore and across the street is a “city hall adult theatre”  with a marquee that reads “NOW PLAYING ‘Erogenous Zoning’. See city council do kinky things with first amendment”. What made me crack up is the ad poster on the right that says “Dinelli Does Central”. Also note the fire hydrant that appears to look like having two large breasts. The caption from the XXX bookstore owners says “Well, there goes the neighborhood”.

State Senator Manny Aragon, the very powerful Pro Temp of the State Senate at the time, was also the City’s trial attorney appointed by Mayor Schultz and he essentially spoke against the ordinance changes saying we would be violating people’s constitutional rights of free speech. To me it was well settled law in the country that Cities had the right to designate zoning where XXX rated businesses could be located. Senator Aragon became visibly infuriated and upset with me when I asked him during the City Council meeting if he was representing the XXX rated businesses or the City. After our very public exchange, our friendly relationship was never the same. The zoning ordinance changes passed and as I understand it are still the law limiting where XXX stores can be allowed in the City. During the next legislative session, Senator Aragon summoned me to meet with him in his Senate Pro Temp Office and we had a very blunt talk and agreed never to discuss matters again with each other in public. It took years for us to set things aside and be civil to each other. That’s politics.

27749978_1724797730987904_5313694952989628191_n

“SUING THE LITTLE VANDALS”

This Trever cartoon was published by the Journal when I was Deputy City Attorney. At the time I had filed over 129 civil lawsuits suing over 300 graffiti vandals and their parents to collect city cleanup costs and damages. We settled virtually all the lawsuits and collected about $250,000 in damages and lawsuits stopped the graffiti. This Trever cartoon was published when I filed a civil lawsuit against the vandals setting off fireworks in the Bosque and the lawyer in the glass looks a lot like me.

27540666_1724844250983252_2607728441985889761_n

“2013 MAYORS RACE”

The  2013  Mayor’s race had only 3 candidates running: Republican Incumbent Mayor Richard Berry, Republican retired  APD Sergeant Paul Heh and me a Democrat. Incumbent Mayor Richard Berry was said to be “Mr. Positive” on Albuquerque, very personable and likeable but in  denial about the city’s high crime rates, the poor performing Albuquerque economy and a police department out of control with police shootings of civilians and declining in numbers. I was retired from the city  but  said to be a “pit bull prosecutor”, and retired Albuquerque Police  Sergeant Paul Heh was known for being blunt and gruff.

The below John Trevor cartoon was published a few weeks before the October election. Trevor depicts a highway and a passenger car driving by three bill boards.  Mayor Berry is depicted on the largest billboard looking bright eyed with a smile and the  billboard saying “Berry: Bullish on Albuquerque.”  I was depicted on a  second smaller billboard with the words “Dinelli: A Pit Bull For Albuquerque” and Trevor embellished me with bushy eyebrows making me look mean and angry as did the expression on my face. The smallest billboard depicts Paul Heh with a very angry look on his face and the words “No More Bull—- Albuquerque!” Notice how Trevor blacked out the “s” word. It was winter and the city at the time had been having hungry bears wondering into  foothill residential areas of the city foraging trash bins for food. A woman passenger in the passing car is saying to the driver as the car passes the billboards “And here I thought bears were the problem.”

Through out the campaign I was always being told I never smiled and was told I was way too  serious to be running for mayor. A once influential political gossip columnist blogger believed to be a Berry supporter said that I was not “likeable” enough person to be Mayor. I was told that I needed to start smiling more if I was ever going to get elected. The problem for me was I could not help being a former prosecutor and a former judge who had to be serious through out my legal career. I could not talk about the city’s high crime rates, our poor economy and the challenges the city was facing with a fake grin on my face and a smile in my voice like so many politicians we see today at city hall, in the state legislature and in congress.

My campaign volunteers collected 5,000 qualifying donations when I only needed  3,000. I was given $360,000 in public finance. Mayor Berry raised $1.1 Million dollars in private donations and Heh raised about $10,000. In the final analysis, Mayor Berry always had the upper hand given the amount of money he had raised and what he spent and the power of incumbency.

Whenever I see this Trevor Cartoon, I have a flashback to the debate forum sponsored by the National Association of Industrial and Office Parks (NAIOP), a contractor and real estate development group that Mayor Berry was once a member. The  NAIOP debate forum was held at the Marriott hotel during a luncheon with an audience of over 300 comprised of  the city’s movers and shakers in the real estate and construction community. A table of Berry’s executive staff sat directly in front of the elevated debate table where the moderator and the candidates were seated. Then Albuquerque Journal Editor Kent Walz was the moderator.

Kent Walz allowed audience members to ask questions. I was asked my position on “project labor agreements” requiring union participation in city building projects which were opposed by NAIOP. I remember vividly  being  loudly “booed” by the NAIOP audience when I said I supported project labor agreements as Walz simply looked on. I felt I had been set up.  Although I was taken aback by the the boos, Walz allowed me to respond to the booing. I pointed out that Mayor Berry was at impasse with virtually all 9 city labor unions at the time including the police union over union negotiated wage increases he suspended and I told the audience that any Mayor worth their salt needed to work with the city unions to be successful and to get things done.

During the NAIOP debate, former APD Sergeant Paul Heh shocked the audience when he said “I call bullshit!” when Berry denied that the city had a drug crime problem.

Comments made by Mayor Berry during the NAIOP debate included “I do not want to live in a world that these gentlemen live in, a world where there is a cloud to every silver lining”.  Berry said to me and former APD Sergeant Heh during the KOAT TV debate “they do not love Albuquerque” which was clearly below the belt given our combined public service of  close to 50 years and I being born and raised here, educated here, raising a family here and practicing law for decades to make a living. But that’s politics.

One thing for sure, APD Sergeant Paul Heh and I never lied to voters about what was happening with our high crime rates and our economy. Notwithstanding, Mayor Berry won by a landslide with only 19% of the voters voting in the lowest municipal voter turnout since 1977. Republicans turned out in droves while Democrats simply stayed home.

Four years later, people finally figured out Mayor Berry and believed what Paul Heh and I were saying during the campaign.  Mayor Berry left office disliked with an approval rating of 32%, especially after he pushed the ART Bus project that destroyed historic central.

27750205_1724984800969197_3188025061085006602_n

COMMENTARY ANALYSIS

There are many times politicians and elected officials who are elected and say and do things that they just have no idea what visions are evoked in the general public’s mind. Political editorial cartoonists throughout the history of this great country of ours have evoked both laughter and downright hostility.

At times, the actions and comments by politicians and elected officials themselves are treated with irreverence by political cartoonist. There are times editorial cartoons do go too far with very serious subjects and are insensitive and insulting but its exclusively up to editors to take responsibility and decide what to publish and not the cartoonist.

Simply put, political editorial cartoons embody one of the highest forms of free speech we have in this country and serve a real function that must be respected. It can be said the editorial political cartoons of John Trevor over 5 decades have made people think, debate and examine closely opposing views and he usually  has done so with a degree of humor.  There have been few exceptions that have been considered offensive, but that is to be expected when it comes to politics in general.

Many thanks to John Trevor for his work over 50 years as a political editorial cartoonist and for promoting the healthy discussion of issues affecting this city and state.

_______________________

POSTSCRIPT

John Trever has published four compilations of his cartoons and below is a photo of the cover of the one published in 2007. The title “Manana Republic” says it all especially having Tony Anaya, Bruce King, Gary Carruthers, Bill Richardson, Gary Johnson, Manny Aragon, Jeff Bingaman and Pete Domenici sitting in a hot air balloon with the state capitol building as the gondola and they are all pointing in different directions. All that is needed now is Governor Susana Martinez eating and throwing pizza from the gondola while Governors Michelle Lujan and Deb Haaland catch a slice from below. You can contact John Trevor or the Albuquerque Journal, PO Box Drawer J, Albuquerque, New Mexico 87103 for more information on the availability of Trevor’s books.

27749953_1725607947573549_4045595286834974_n

Mike Voorhees Guest Opinion Column: Discrediting Dan Lewis And City Council’s Elimination Of  City Recognition Of Neighborhood Coalitions;  The Truth About Neighborhood Coalitions And The Work of Westside Coalition of Neighborhood Associations; Dinelli Commentary: Contact City Council And Tell Them To Repeal Ordinance That Eliminated City Recognition Of Neighborhood Coalitions

BACKGROUND INTRODUCTION

The Albuquerque City Council has enacted four measures misleadingly labeled the Better Neighborhoods Package. The legislation was passed under the guise of cutting red tape to allow development projects. The Better Neighborhoods package consists of two ordinances and two memorials. The two ordinances make dramatic changes to the Neighborhood Association Recognition Ordinance and severely limit the rights of appeals to stop developments. The two memorials request the New Mexico Legislature to define who has standing and the right to appeal developments and mandates direct and costly appeals to the courts.

The most egregious of the four measures is O-26-61. This ordinance eliminates formal city recognition of neighborhood coalitions and eliminates automatic development notices to them. It eliminates the requirement for developers to act in good faith and to cooperate with the very neighborhoods they want to develop in. O-26-61 strips standing from neighborhood coalitions to appeal developments. It requires neighborhood associations to redraw boundaries, adding extensive appeal conditions. Loss of city recognition of neighborhood coalitions means loss of notification to individuals and neighborhoods that are likely to be harmed by any development. Thirteen neighborhood associations will now lose city recognition or will have to kick out their county neighbors as members.

Ordinance O-26-61 was introduced and moved forward within two weeks for a full council vote without a committee hearing and no community discussion. It passed on a 5-4 vote. Voting “yes” were Republican councilors Dan Lewis, Dan Champine and Renee Grout and Democrats Stephanie Telles and Tammy Fiebelkorn. Voting “no” were Democratic City Council President Klarissa Peña, Democratic councilors Joaquín Baca and Nichole Rogers and Republican Brook Bassan. Mayor Tim Keller signed O-26-61 into law, falsely arguing that neighborhood coalitions were legally representing neighborhood associations without their consent.

Republican Dan Lewis was the sponsor of the “Better Neighborhoods” package. At the time of introduction, Councilor Lewis said neighborhood coalitions in general are “undemocratic” as decision-making bodies. Lewis provided no evidence to support this false assertion. Lewis said O-26-61 “right-sizes” neighborhood representation by putting authority back with “the neighborhoods that are closest and have a direct stake.” Lewis said appeals often come after a development has spent years moving through the city process. Lewis assailed  the Westside Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA), which is  in his district, as one of the “worst offenders” revealing his true motivations. That neighborhood appeal was repeatedly denied but eventually won in State District Court.

MIKE VOORHEES GUEST OPINION COLUMN

Mike Voorhees, whose educational background includes degrees in geography and engineering, moved to Albuquerque in 1995 to help grow the aerospace sector. Since then, he has been involved in various community organizations and activities, including a Habitat for Humanity house build, open space trail repair, and advocacy for safety and education in hot air ballooning.  In 2024, after exposing multiple improper actions of the City’s Planning Department, he was elected to the Executive Committee of the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA) as Member at Large, and subsequently elected Vice President of WSCONA.  In 2004, he was presented the FBI Director’s Award for “Exceptional Service in the Public Interest” for his work protecting and improving the security posture of critical infrastructure in New Mexico against both natural and human-caused threats.

EDITOR’S DISCLAIMER: Mike Voorhees submitted the following guest column to be published as a public service announcement only with no compensation and no solicitations requested nor paid by him or West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations to publisher www.PeteDinelli.com.  

Discrediting Dan Lewis And City Council’s Elimination Of  City Recognition Of Neighborhood Coalitions;  The Truth And Importance Of Neighborhood Coalitions And The Work of Westside Coalition of Neighborhood Associations

Now that voters across the nation have repudiated the unconstrained greed, corruption, and recklessness of the Developer In Chief—who’s disrespect of cultural heritage, historic treasures, and irreplaceable public lands has outraged people of all walks of life—it is time to repudiate the unconstrained greed, corruption, and recklessness of some of Albuquerque’s developers and any politicians who may be in their pocket.

ALBUQUERQUE DOES NOT HAVE HOUSING CRISIS BUT AN AFFORDABILITY CRISIS

Much has been written by corporate media, beholden to business interests, pushing a false narrative that Albuquerque, like so many cities, has a housing crisis. The actual crisis is one of affordability, but that story is seldom told as it is inconvenient to those pushing a consumerist and uncontrolled growth agenda.

Quite cleverly, the private-equity-fueled campaign goes something like this:

 “The reason why housing is expensive is a lack of supply, and the reason why there is a lack of supply is due to complicated government regulations and red tape, foisted upon us by pesky environmentalists and community activists.  If we can cut that red tape and eliminate the regulations, the housing industry will build a utopia of abundance for us all.”

While this explanation sounds plausible and superficial searches seem to support it, unfortunately, this story and its entire premise are not remotely true.  Let’s look at the actual facts first.

Mayor Keller often quotes a figure that Albuquerque needs an additional 50,000 housing units right away.  Sometimes he says 30,000 housing units. The origin of this claim is a poorly constructed study based upon unsupported assumptions of large population growth, covering a multi-county area.  Yet as of this writing, the Albuquerque metro area has approximately 376,025 occupied housing units and 25,695 vacant housing units, which is a vacancy rate of roughly 6.5%.  To put that in context, Albuquerque has approximately 3.3 to 3.4 vacant market-viable housing units for every unhoused person.

ALBUQUERQUE’S DECLING POPULATION

Rather than growing, the population of Albuquerque has been declining since 2020, dropping from a peak of 564,888 residents in 2020 down to an estimated 555,119 in 2026 (a decrease of roughly 1.71%).  Albuquerque Public Schools just reported losing approximately 20,000 students over the past decade, leaving many schools operating significantly below their intended capacities.

Demographers are debating whether 2026 is the first year of a nationwide switch from population growth to decline, as the fertility rate remains below replacement coupled with draconian immigration purges.  In fact five states have experienced population losses, led by Vermont (-0.29%), Hawaii (-0.15%), California (-0.02%), New Mexico, and West Virginia.

Some 6,791 new apartment units have been built in the metro area over the past ten years.  Albuquerque has some 58,906 existing units as of the end of Q1 2026, with 619 units under construction.  From 2020 to the present, the City has issued over 14,000 building permits for single family homes.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING SHORTAGE

Albuquerque has plenty of housing.  What is missing is affordable housing.

Since 2020, during a period in which the population has fallen and rental inventories have dramatically increased, rental prices in Albuquerque have risen by 40%. That cannot be attributed to simplistic supply and demand.

When developers get their way and environmental regulations are gutted, those developers don’t begin a spree of affordable housing projects.  Instead, they push high-rent, multi-story projects wherever they can—regardless of whether those looming monoliths have access to parks, open space, groceries, transportation, adequate parking, or neighborhood scale businesses designed for a sustainable or walkable community. 

The developers also push projects of other hard-to-audit businesses like massive self-storage complexes, gas stations coupled to convenience stores with liquor sales and Convertible Virtual Currency (CVC) Kiosks—also known as Crypto ATMs—and of course the ubiquitous car wash, which as the fictional TV show Breaking Bad showcased is an excellent opportunity for money laundering. 

Perhaps it is merely a coincidence that according to the Suspicious Activity Reports data of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), the vast majority of suspected illicit financial activity in the real estate sector comes from property management companies, real estate investment firms, realty and brokerage companies, and real estate development companies.

Developers also seem to love building corporate franchised drive-through fast food restaurants without regard to impact on traffic flow or air quality, and which degrade the supposed pedestrian-friendly walkability the city claims to promote.  The proliferation of fast-food chains is also displacing local family-owned restaurants which have been part of the unique fabric of Albuquerque for decades.

To help sell this great bait-and-switch, straw man villains were needed, and thus the relentless labeling of Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions as NIMBYs (Not In My Back Yard). If the people most engaged in promoting livable cities and establishing policies balancing the needs and desires of the community could be tarred with being obstructionists, then the interests of private equity could sweep aside regulations and rapidly buy up newly rezoned property for haphazard construction regardless of long term viability, because out-of-state hedge funds and speculators will flip these projects, extracting any value long before the blight and land price manipulation collapses the viability of the city itself.

THE SUCCESS STORIES OF WSCONA

So who are these NIMBY bogeymen?  My city councilor, Dan Lewis, loves to hate WSCONA, the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations.  So what has WSCONA been doing to attract Lewis’ opprobrium?  Let’s take a look:

WSCONA is a collection of neighborhood associations (NAs), homeowner associations (HOAs), and other residents whose neighborhoods no longer have an NA or never had one to begin with.  As such, it helps to keep its members up to date on the policies and goings on of the city, county, and state; invites law enforcement to give updates on its policing practices and crime statistics; invites elected officials and community leaders to present policy agendas and receive feedback; and advocates for the wise use of taxpayer funds to meet community needs.

WSCONA membership currently includes 27 neighborhood organizations, consisting of City-recognized neighborhood associations, unrecognized neighborhood associations, and homeowner associations, and two individual members from two additional neighborhoods that currently have no neighborhood organization.  The member organizations of WSCONA serve over 21,000 households. Elections are held each year for both officers and members of the Executive Committee (EC), and the EC currently has nine members.  Additional neighborhoods located west of the Rio Grande are eligible for membership in WSCONA and are encouraged to join.

WSCONA has been recognized by the City for over a decade, and during that time it would receive notices of proposed development projects within or near its boundaries, and would pass these notices to its members, including HOAs which otherwise receive no notification. WSCONA often attends meetings and hearings on proposed developments—especially when those developments don’t comply with the existing regulations that protect the livability of the neighborhoods and the community as a whole—and in those meetings WSCONA offers alternative suggestions on how to improve those development projects.  On rare occasions, when a development falls so far outside of compliance with the city’s rules and regulations, or when the City fails to abide by its own laws in how it grants approval to such projects, WSCONA will undertake administrative or legal action to resolve the issue.

To give you an idea of the projects in which WSCONA has been involved, we have compiled a representative sample of projects for which we advocated, projects that we successfully influenced to be better than first proposed, and projects which we have stopped.

WSCONA has supported many neighborhoods in addressing concerns related to land use proposals. Much time and research have been spent reviewing development proposals to ensure they meet the Albuquerque Comprehensive Plan’s goals and policies, as well as zoning regulations. This work helps preserve Albuquerque’s unique landscapes and our quality of life. WSCONA does not get involved frivolously.

Following are major develops that WSCONA became involved with:

The Vista de la Luz Plaza: 2007-2008: WSCONA offered design improvement suggestions to the proposed strip mall which had no plans for any windows looking east to the Sandia mountains. By adding windows to the plan, it enabled the development to attract Jinja Bar & Restaurant Westside as a Tennent, allowing the restaurant to feature stunning views that otherwise would have been blocked. This business has been going strong ever since.

The Walmart proposed for Coors and Montano: 2011- 2013: WSCONA supported Taylor Ranch Neighborhood Association (TRNA) and surrounding neighborhoods’ efforts to oppose the Walmart, a large retail facility proposed for Coors and Montano, adjacent to the Bosque’s Rio Grande Valley State Park and Bosque School. It did not meet the Coors Corridor Sector development plan, the Goals and Policies of the Comp Plan, the Westside Strategic Plan, or the Big Box ordinance. As a result, a more appropriate shopping center was later approved that is more walkable for the surrounding community and provides a variety of businesses including a Sprouts, PetSmart, LaCumbre Brewing, Grassburger, etc…

Poole Property: 2018- 2021: Adjacent to the Rio Grande Bosque and Oxbow wetlands, the Poole property is another example of WSCONA supporting TRNA and surrounding neighborhoods in opposing a subdivision that did not adhere to the IDO’s protective zoning requirements. Development of this area would have created numerous problems for existing homeowners and had subdivision infrastructure plans that directly impacted the sensitive nature of the wetlands. Because of the Community’s involvement, this area was ultimately acquired as City Open Space after working with the applicants. The Poole property now provides needed protection for the Bosque, preserves fantastic views, and creates an opportunity for residents to enjoy a beautiful natural setting with abundant wildlife.

 Saranam: 2020: WSCONA also joined TRNA’s support for Saranam, a two-year transitional living facility that helps families avoid homelessness and become sustainable after attending a rigorous 2 year education program to prepare them for an independent life.

 La Cuentista Open Space: WSCONA joined with TRNA to advocate for the purchase of 60 acres of La Cuentista Open Space. This land buffers the Petroglyph escarpment and preserves the culturally important view shed, rock outcroppings, wildlife, and juniper forest within those boundaries, while providing recreational trails for nearby residents and visitors alike.

 IDO amendment Update: WSCONA has been involved in numerous meetings and thousands of hours regarding the IDO amendment process. Since the IDO was enacted in 2017, there have been more than 700 amendments—which is an absurd number—and most of these amendments have been requested by developers to allow more generic construction without reflecting the local character, cultural heritage, or historic styles for which Albuquerque is known and which help attract tourists the world over. WSCONA has testified about why it is important to maintain these zoning protections that help make Albuquerque a unique place to live.

DEEP DIVE INTO COMPLICATED SAGA

Now let’s take a deep dive into one property at the center of multiple appeals—the vacant property on the southwest corner of Paseo del Norte and Kimmick, which can be seen as you drive west on Paseo as you crest the hill of the escarpment.  This saga is long, and so patience is necessary to even read a brief summary:

Before the IDO, the entire parcel was zoned to accommodate low level neighborhood scale businesses while preserving the views and cultural heritage near Petroglyph National Monument.  Hundreds of families bought homes in the adjacent neighborhoods with the expectation that the City would honor this commitment.

However, the first proposal the current developer tried to get approved for this property was an enormous three-story tall self storage facility that would have blocked views to and from Petroglyph National Monument and its volcanoes, obstructed views to the Jemez Mountains for neighborhoods to the south, and would have interfered with traditional cultural practices of 29 pueblos and tribes for whom the petroglyphs and volcanoes are sacred. 

Several neighbors and I, along with the Santa Fe Village Neighborhood Association and WSCONA opposed the self storage proposal in a facilitated meeting.  The developer ignored our concerns.  We then opposed the self storage proposal in a Zoning Hearing Examiner (ZHE) hearing, and the ZHE ruled in our favor.  The developer appealed to the Land Use Hearing Officer (LUHO) who remanded the issue back to the ZHE with instructions.  The developer ignored the instructions and presented misleading information.  The ZHE ordered an additional facilitated meeting, during which the developer would not budge.  After several ZHE continuances, the developer finally agreed to withdraw the application.

Importantly, during this period the City was not requiring nor facilitating any outreach for the Pueblos and Tribes who have ties to this land dating back millennia.

Shortly after the self storage application saga began, the developer held a facilitated meeting to announce plans for a ten-building three-story tall apartment complex on the southern portion of the same property.  From the start he insisted that this would be high end market rate luxury apartments, with zero units dedicated to affordable housing.  We expressed disappointment at the lack of affordable housing, but we also informed him that the height of the planned buildings would violate the zoning ordinances and comprehensive plans.  The developer ignored our concerns.  We reached out to the Pueblos and Tribes, in addition to the residents in the nearby neighborhoods, to let them know what was being planned. The developer then proceeded to get his plan approved by the Development Review Board (DRB) which as a matter of law had no jurisdiction to do so.

The DRB used outdated and inaccurate maps to justify their approval, so I, along with WSCONA and the Pueblo of Laguna appealed to the LUHO, wherein the timing of the filing required us to work over the Thanksgiving weekend to meet the 15 day deadline.  (Many of the these developer applications are submitted just before holidays when the timeline for any resulting appeals conflict with holidays when most people are busy with celebrations, and the developers often get away with gross violations as a result.)  The LUHO ruled against us as did the City Council, so we appealed that case to district court. The district court improperly ruled against us, and so we appealed to the Court of Appeals, which found that the City had indeed violated its own rules, and therefore overturned the DRB approval and remanded the issue to the Environmental Planning Commission (EPC).

Shortly after the apartment complex approval by the DRB, the developer realized that the project they had proposed violated a view protection overlay zone.  They therefore reached out to Councilor Lewis, who sponsored an amendment to the Integrated Development Ordinance (IDO) at the request of the developer that would limit how to apply the view protections for Petroglyph National Monument, in order to exempt the apartment complex from following the existing rules.  We informed the City that such sponsorship by Lewis would require him to recuse himself in any proceedings on this matter.  City staff recommended against Lewis’ amendment.  The EPC voted against Lewis’ amendment.  Nevertheless, Lewis revived the amendment in the LUPZ committee. He moved the issue and voted for it.  In full council, he again moved and voted for it.  At no time did he entertain our request for his recusal.  Thus we appealed to district court, which ruled in our favor, finding that Lewis unlawfully prejudged the issue with bias in violation of his duty to act impartially, and therefore the enactment was reversed by the court and remanded to the City Council, with the stipulation that Councilor Lewis not be allowed to participate in the remand.  The City appealed to the Court of Appeals, but the Court of Appeals upheld the ruling in favor of WSCONA.

While the above court actions proceeded, the developer continued to try and advance the project through multiple improper subdivisions that were approved by Development Hearing Officers (DHOs) who failed to even notify WSCONA that the hearings were taking place.  It is hard to express opposition to something when the City keeps it a secret.  As it turns out, one of the DHOs was actually in the employ of one of the property owners for the development in question at the time of his first ruling, but this fact was also kept secret by using the State’s LLC privacy rules.

While we waited for the Mandate of the Court from the first case overturning the DRB approval to make its way back to the City, the developer attempted to rush through an approval via the EPC which was predicated upon the illegal subdivision which was conducted by the DRB that had lacked jurisdiction in the first place.  During that EPC hearing, City staff admitted under oath that the subdivision and related notice were invalid and inaccurate, and an appeal would likely prevail.  The EPC was informed of the Court of Appeals ruling, but chose to ignore this, approving the Site Plan nonetheless.  WSCONA was forced yet again to appeal to the LUHO, along with the Pueblos of Laguna and Santa Clara, however this time, because Councilor Lewis had convinced the City Council to enact punitive laws that year limiting the standing of Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions, it would be even more difficult, including a new requirement for obtaining dozens of petition signatures from neighbors over the holiday between Christmas and New Years.

Interestingly, in an unrelated case which involved even taller buildings that would have disrupted the view shed of the volcanoes of Petroglyph National Monument, Judge Barela Shepard ruled that the City had no authority under state law to limit the standing of anyone, including Neighborhood Associations and Coalitions.

So back to the apartments, the LUHO again ruled against us as did the City Council, with Councilor Lewis again failing to recuse himself.  We have since joined the appeal to district court filed by the Pueblo of Laguna, where it lies today.

But wait, there is more. The developer switched plans from locating a neighborhood scale grocery store on the northeast corner of the property to a gas station with liquor sales.  This would need a conditional use approval from the ZHE.  Apparently the developer was hoping that such an approval would establish that the unlawful subdivision of the property was a fait accompli and could not be reversed, and that would sever the lot for the rest of the property, in effect doing in fact what Councilor Lewis’ amendment on the view protections was stopped from doing.  So we have appealed that to the LUHO.

REPEAL LEWIS/CITY COUNCIL PUNITIVE LEGISLATION

As complicated and convoluted as this synopsis is, the full story and details are even more troubling. If you find the behavior of the City and the developer unacceptable, perhaps you will consider donating to our legal fund.  We are unpaid volunteers fighting corruption and gross incompetence at every step.  And since we have successfully appealed these issues, the City Council has enacted more punitive legislation, namely O-26-60 and O-26-61, of course sponsored by Councilor Dan Lewis.  One of these would charge coalitions like WSCONA $1000 to appeal an improperly granted development approval, but only charge developers $300 if their project was denied.  If you think this sounds unconstitutional, that is because it is.

What can be done about these unconstitutional ordinances?  Two options come to mind.  The first is yet another law suit, which would cost the plaintiff and the City thousands of dollars.  The second option would be for the City Council to repeal them, saving taxpayer money and restoring the Constitutional rights of Burqueños.  Repealing is the better option. If just one other councilor joined Councilors Rogers, Bassan, Baca, and Peña, repeal could be swift, and that councilor would rejoin the right side of history.

The issues we and other coalitions have opposed include policies that would make it harder for young families to buy a home of their own, would create a permanent rental class forced to pay ever more to hedge fund controlled landlords, and keep the people from having a say in whether we want data centers in our city. The City often ignores the need to ensure our community has enough water; it occasionally disregards concerns over rising heat and fire danger; and squanders the cultural heritage of our city that contributes to our economy—tourists are not interested in another city full of generic strip malls and drive throughs.  If standing up for these values makes us NIMBYs, so be it, but we have never opposed actual affordable housing projects.

To learn more about WISCONA and its advocacy for sustainable and live able neighborhood hoods and our community please visit:

wsconanm.org

RESPECTFULLY,

Mike Voorhees

DINELLI COMMENTARY AND ANALYSIS

A POLITICALLY MOTIVATED AND VINDICTIVE DAN LEWIS

It is clear that  the four city council actions sponsored by Dan Lewis were politically motivated. Lewis has an extensive history of tangling and disagreeing with the West Side Coalition of Neighborhood Associations (WSCONA) who have often objected to many of his efforts on the city council and development projects that may affect their homes and neighborhoods.

City Councilor Dan Lewis is one of the longest serving City Councilors having been elected to three 4 year terms. During the last five years Dan Lewis has exhibited a pattern of downright hostility towards his own constituents who oppose or who disagree with his votes on policy and legislation. Lewis has a reputation during city council meetings of berating, insulting or ignoring members of the public who disagree with him. Lewis is known to be constantly on his phone or texting during city council public comments. Lewis is known to go out of his way to offend citizens by leaving meetings very early on not to return.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS SUBSIDIZED HOUSING

The term “affordable housing” is about as misleading as it gets. It is a term way too often used by elected officials and politicians to simply declare a crisis with inflated numbers that shows there is not enough housing that allows the poor or low-income people to rent or buy a home and call their own. Housing prices and rental costs never come down. The more appropriate term that should be used is “subsidized” housing where it’s clear what is needed is subsidized funding for those who cannot afford to buy outright or rent and need assistance.

The housing shortage is related to economics, the development community’s inability to keep up with supply and demand and the public’s inability to purchase housing or qualify for housing mortgage loans. The shortage of rental properties has resulted in dramatic increases in rents. It’s clear that the City of Albuquerque and the state of New Mexico are suffering from a shortage of housing, but that does not mean it is all affordable housing.

It is a false narrative that increasing density in established neighborhoods will somehow create affordable housing and allow for needed commercial development when it will not. Instead, it will lead to gentrification as investors buy up established neighborhoods or historical neighborhoods to develop into high end housing. Market forces will prevail and developers will build to make a profit and not build affordable housing. What is totally ignored with proposing to change zoning law is the millions, if not billions of dollars, that are already being spent and  invested by the city and state to build and to address affordable housing.

The very real consequences of passage of O-26-61 are clear and are as follows:

  • Thirteen neighborhood associations will either lose recognition or have to kick out their county neighbors as members.
  • Loss of recognition equals the loss of notification to those individuals and neighborhoods that are likely to be harmed by the development.
  • It removes the requirement for developers to act in good faith and to cooperate with the very neighborhoods they chose to develop.

It is clear that the city’s council’s enactment of the Dan Lewis sponsored Better Neighborhoods Package was to benefit  the development, real estate and investment community to the determent of established neighborhoods. It will have a major impact eliminating the rights of neighborhood coalitions to challenge developments. When a new apartment complex or commercial development is proposed in neighborhoods that will have a detrimental impact on the neighborhood, especially historical or established neighborhoods, individual property owners often look to neighborhood coalitions to help appeal or challenge the projects because the individuals do not have the financial resources of their own to oppose developers.

 Passage of the Better Neighborhoods package is an effort to deconstruct guardrails and protections. It marginalizes the voices of neighborhoods and city residents. Passage of the Better Neighborhoods package was a sellout by Keller and the Albuquerque City Council of the citizens of Albuquerque, property owners and neighborhood associations and coalitions in favor of the development community.

CITY COUNCIL REPEAL“BETTER NEIGHBORHOODS” PACKAGE

The four City Councilors who voted “NO” to enact O-26-61 were Democrat City Council President Klarissa Peña, Progressive Democrats Jaquin Baca and Nichole Rogers and Republican Brook Bassan. One or all 4 should take immediate steps to repeal O-26-61 and the “Better Neighborhoods” package by sponsoring and introducing a resolution or ordinance repealing the legislation and demanding public hearings before the City Council’s Land Use and Planning committee to allow the public sufficient time weigh in and to avoid the  two week rush job that came with enactment of O-26-61.

Contact your City Councilor and tell them to repeal O-26-61 and protest the underhanded way it was enacted.

CITY COUNCIL CONTACT INFORMATION

CITY COUNCIL PHONE: (505) 768-3100

CITY COUNCILOR AND SUPPORT STAFF EMAILS

stelles@cabq.gov

stephenchavez@cabq.gov

joaquinbaca@cabq.gov

bacajoaquin9@gmail.com

namolina@cabq.gov

kpena@cabq.gov

cquezada@cabq.gov

bbassan@cabq.gov

dawnmarie@cabq.gov

danlewis@cabq.gov

galvarez@cabq.gov

nrogers@cabq.gov

district6@cabq.gov

tfiebelkorn@cabq.gov

seanforan@cabq.gov

dchampine@cabq.gov

eromero@cabq.gov

rgrout@cabq.gov

rrmiller@cabq.gov

ipadilla@cabq.gov  (Director of Council Services)

mmmontoya@cabq.gov (Council Clerk)

 

Indigenous Journalists Association Condemns As Racist Albuquerque Journal’s Trevor Cartoon; Journal Managing Editor Bennett Refuses To Apologize, Claims Regret Not Thinking More Deeply About Cultural Ramifications; Not The First Time For Journal; COMMENTARY: Journal Had Right To Publish But Editor’s Knew Better Than To Publish Claiming It Was Cartoonist Opinion, Not Papers

On Sunday, November 9, the Albuquerque Journal published a John Trevor editorial cartoon depicting a donkey ostensibly representing the  Democratic Party mascot standing behind Governor Elect Deb Haaland with the donkey waving a foam glove with one finger pointing up with the glove having the printed words on it “1st Native American Woman Governor”.  A cowboy is depicted with the initials “NM” on his hat with a Zia symbol emblazed on the front of his shirt with the cowboy ostensibly representing the State of New Mexico. The Zia symbol is inaccurate in that it has 4 sets of bars of 3 bars in a cluster around the circle when there should be 4 bars in each of the cluster of bars around the circle. The NM cowboy appears taller than Haaland as he looks down on her with a furrowed brow on his face as he very sarcastically says to  Haaland  “YES, CONGRTUALTIONS ON THAT! NOW LETS  TALK ABOUT OUR BEING 50TH ON THE TOTEM POLL …”

The Trevor cartoon was posted on my FACEBOOK page where I labeled it as being degrading and racist. It was a “cowboys and Indians” trope unbecoming of John Trevor and his work with the Albuquerque Journal. The reaction to the post was swift and true. Over seven days, according to my FACEBOOK “insights”, the post had 29,362 views, 16,336 viewers, 369 thumbs ups and 259 comments and 70 Shares. The overwhelming majority of the comments were supportive of the argument that the editorial cartoon was indeed racist.  Many comments included a condemnation of the Albuquerque Journal and its biased reporting over many decades.  A very small handful of comments suggested that there was nothing wrong with the cartoon nor the criticism towards Haaland and the Democratic Party.

INDIGENOUS JOURNALISTS ASSOCIATION DEMANDS APOLOGY

The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) supports Indigenous journalists, advocates for press freedom and promotes accurate, contextual coverage of Indigenous peoples and communities. On November 12, the Indigenous Journalists Association issued the following press release:

IJA condemns racist cartoon published by the Albuquerque Journal

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
11/12/2026
Media contact — ija@indigenousjournalists.org 

“The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) condemns the Albuquerque Journal’s decision to publish an editorial cartoon by John Trever that relies on racist stereotypes to depict New Mexico Governor-elect Deb Haaland, a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna. The cartoon appeared in the Sunday, Nov. 8 print edition. IJA calls on the Journal to issue a public apology and explain how the cartoon was approved for publication. 

The cartoon references a “totem pole” to turn Haaland’s Indigenous identity into a punch line. In doing so, the Journal incorrectly attributed a cultural practice of tribes in the Pacific Northwest to a Pueblo woman, and the practice itself was not properly characterized. That choice reinforces the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable.Totem poles serve a specific cultural purpose and should not be a punchline. 

While political cartoonists have every right to scrutinize Haaland’s record, her policy proposals and the challenges facing New Mexico, the Journal’s editors are responsible for what they choose to publish. Readers deserve political commentary that holds public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures. 

IJA urges the Journal to take the following steps:

  • Publish an apology in print and online that names the racist stereotypes in the cartoon and takes responsibility for publishing it.
  • Explain how the cartoon was approved and identify what editors will change in their review of cartoons and other opinion content.
  • Provide opportunities to educate staff in order to report for the community it serves rather than further marginalizing the Indigenous community. 
  • Seek and utilize resources by IJA and other organizations. IJA provides newsroom training to ensure coverage of Indigenous issues, people and communities is accurate, ethical and culturally appropriate, through the Indigenous Media Initiative. 

New Mexico and the Southwest are home to many Native communities and Indigenous people are among the Journal’s readers, sources and neighbors. They deserve the same care, accuracy and respect that every community should expect from its newspaper.

Read the full statement here: https://indigenousjournalists.org/…/ija-condemns…/

ALBUQUERQUE JOURNAL MANAGING EDITOR’S COLUMN  

On November 14, the Albuquerque Journal published the following editorial opinion column by Managing Editor James Bennett on Page A-10:

EDITOR’S NOTES

BENNETT: Addressing Haaland editorial cartoon concerns

Drawing’s cultural implications deserve attention, and we’ll learn from feedback, criticism

BY James Bennett,  managing editor of the Journal.

“Editorial cartoonist John Trever sends rough drafts to Journal Opinion Editor Ryan Boetel and me every Wednesday afternoon.

The 50-year veteran did the same thing last week. The drawing, which was published Nov. 8, depicted Democratic Gov.-elect Deb Haaland.

Text in the cartoon showed a supporter next to Haaland, waving a foam finger that said: “1st Native American Woman Governor.” Another character, with “NM” on his cowboy hat, replied: “Yes, congratulations on that. Now let’s talk about our being 50th on the totem pole…”

Trever’s weekly cartoon was similar to a column I wrote the morning after the election, celebrating the historic nature of Haaland’s victory. It also asked what she would do differently than Democratic Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham, whose eight years in New Mexico did not lift the state out of the basement in national ratings from education to healthcare.

The difference between Trever’s cartoon and my column? I did not use a throwaway line about a totem pole as a punch line.

His cartoon raised some eyebrows among readers, who emailed me about it. But that’s been par for the course for Trever through his half century at the Journal. He draws piercing cartoons that elicit reaction — good and bad.

This one, though, comes on the heels of Haaland’s historic election. Not many readers liked seeing the Journal pour cold water on the celebration.

“They were emphasizing that she was the first Native American woman elected governor,” the 83-year-old Trever said Friday, just before at event at Albuquerque’s Weems Gallery honoring his 50 years at the Journal. “My point was there’s something of a bigger concern — that the state is nearly last on every list that matters. That’s what she has to deal with — the state’s poor rankings. That was the bottom line of what I drew.”

The Indigenous Journalists Association, which labeled the cartoon as racist, was not very happy. They emailed me Thursday evening.

 “The cartoon references a ‘totem pole’ to turn Haaland’s Indigenous identity into a punch line,” the group wrote in a letter to me. “In doing so, the Journal incorrectly attributed a cultural practice of tribes in the Pacific Northwest to a Pueblo woman, and the practice itself was not properly characterized. That choice reinforces the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable. Totem poles serve a specific cultural purpose and should not be a punchline.”

They were right in saying further that editors were responsible for what we choose to publish. The old English idiom, “Low man on the totem pole,” is actually incorrect. In many Pacific Northwest First Nations and Native American traditions, the low man is often the most revered.

“Readers deserve political commentary that holds public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures,” the statement continued.

In summary, here is what the group asked us to do:

  • Publish an apology in print and online that names the racist stereotypes in the cartoon and take responsibility for it.
  • Explain how the cartoon was approved.
  • Provide opportunities to educate staff onthe Indigenous community.
  • Seek and utilize resources provided by IJA and other journalism organizations.

Here is our reaction: We will not apologize for our cartoonist’s point of view. Asking tough questions about our state’s future is our job. Trever’s commentary came from a place of civic concern, not prejudice.

But we do regret that we as editors did not think more deeply about the cultural ramifications of the language used to make that point. We will learn from that.

We also will reach out to the Indigenous Journalists Association to learn more about their newsroom training resources.

“New Mexico and the Southwest are home to many Native communities and Indigenous people are among the Journal’s readers, sources and neighbors. They deserve the same care, accuracy and respect that every community should expect from its newspaper,” the group said in closing its statement.

I also contacted Stacey Lee, a Journal Community Council member and a member of the Navajo Nation. She said each tribe has its own traditions, and many are sacred.

“The cartoon has a character speak to Gov.-elect Haaland using a tradition that belongs to a different Indigenous people,” Lee said. “To me, that suggests the speaker does not respect who she is and it comes across as belittling. More than that, it shows a habit of grouping all Indigenous people together as one, which is not the correct way to see us. Each tribe is its own nation with its own identity.”

Lee encouraged us to consider having someone from the Indigenous community review content like this before publication.

“Many people simply do not know how sacred these traditions are. Sharing that understanding can make this a teaching moment for our whole community, and I would welcome that conversation,” the Albuquerque banker added.

Through the years, I have lived in states with large Native American communities — from Arizona to Oklahoma and now New Mexico. I have covered everything from cultural events to elections and sporting events.

I thought I knew more than I really did. 

Indigenous people are our leaders, friends, neighbors and readers. They deserve better from me as an editor.

The link to the Journal Bennett column is here

https://www.abqjournal.com/news/bennett-addressing-haaland-editorial-cartoon-concerns/3162165

NOT THE FIRST TIME

This is not the first-time controversy over a political editorial cartoon published by the Albuquerque Journal has sparked controversy and a demand for an apology from the paper.

On February 7, 2018, the Albuquerque Journal published on its editorial page an inflammatory political cartoon by national syndicated political cartoonist Sean Delonas depicting a frightened white couple holding their hands up in the air apparently being robbed by two MS-13 gang members pointing a gun at the couple, and depicting a terrorist strapped with lighted bomb fuses and holding a bloody machete.

The man is quoted telling his wife: “Now Honey … I believe they prefer to be called ‘Dreamers’ … or future Democrats …”

The cartoon sent the clear, false and inflammatory message that all dreamers and Democrats are criminal gang members and terrorists willing to kill or commit suicide to kill. The cartoon was swiftly condemned by readers and elected officials, both Republican and Democrat, as being “misguided”, “bigoted”, and described as an example of “ignorance, racism and hatred”.

A protest erupted over the cartoon at the Journal Center and others called for people to cancel their Albuquerque Journal subscriptions. Within two days, the Albuquerque Journal issued an apology and said it would better screen political cartoons it publishes on its editorial page.

Then Albuquerque Journal Editor Karen Moses said the cartoon was “poking at President Trump’s rhetoric” and said this:

“In hindsight, instead of generating debate, this cartoon only inflamed emotions. This was not the intent, and for that, the Journal apologizes. … I also want to reiterate that we do not agree with many of the opinions expressed on the editorial pages, which are intended to encourage debate. Also, the editorial board decides what to publish on these pages, and that is separate from the newsroom and its reporters.”

In describing the Journal’s rationale for choosing to publish the cartoon, then Editorial Page Editor D’ Val Westphal said “the mission of an editorial page is to explore all sides of an issue, to make people think and debate and examine closely the opposing view of an argument. Unfortunately, this cartoon did not inspire that kind of discussion.”

The Albuquerque Journal’s apology was viewed by many as an effort to control the damage and lacking sincerity and somewhat hollow.

https://www.politico.com/story/2018/02/09/albuquerque-journal-apologizes-cartoon-400997

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/02/09/584686212/albuquerque-newspaper-apologizes-for-racist-cartoon-about-dreamers

COMMENTARY AND ANALYIS

A regret is no apology. It is always very difficult for anyone to admit they are wrong and that they have made a major mistake doing their job. It’s even more difficult for management to apologize for the actions of an employee and take full responsibility. It appears to be  especially so when you’re the very new managing editor of the state’s largest newspaper and you consider the paper you work for as the “paper of record” for the community. Such is the case with Albuquerque Journal’s managing editor James Bennett’s November 14 column expressing regret  for publishing the cartoon with no apology.

The paper’s managing editor James Bennett is known to be a very prolificate writer since being hired by the Albuquerque Journal eight months ago in April, 2026 as the managing editor. Many of Bennett’s columns appear on the front page of the Albuquerque Journal with his photo and top of the fold banner headlines. However, his editorial opinion column entitled “Addressing Haaland editorial cartoon concerns” was published on a Saturday, when readership is likely low, on last page A-10 at and below the fold. One has to wonder why it was not on the Albuquerque Journal front page with a banner headline on a Sunday when readership is likely higher?

Although buried on page A-10 of  the Journal, Bennett’s opinion column was defiant when he wrote “we will not apologize for our cartoonist’s point of view” and then he acknowledges that editors are responsible for what they choose to publish. Bennett came close to an apology when he wrote “I thought I knew more than I really did. Indigenous people are our leaders, friends, neighbors and readers. They deserve better from me as an editor.”

FIRST AMENDMENT FREEDOM OF SPEECH AND FREEDOM OF THE PRESS

Under the United States Constitution First Amendment guarantees of freedom of speech and of the press, the Albuquerque Journal had every right to publish Trevor’s political cartoon on its editorial page, but that does not mean it should have published it. Just because one has the right to free speech does not mean you should  “mouth off” inflammatory opinions to get a rise out of people. The Trevor cartoon was viewed as racist, degrading and inflammatory by many readers. The Journal editors should not have published it in the first place.

John Trevor is celebrating 50 years as the Albuquerque Journal editorial cartoonist.  By publishing the Trevor cartoon, like it or not by the editors, it became an editorial endorsement by the Journal. Bennett admitted as much when he wrote “Trever’s weekly cartoon was similar to a column I wrote the morning after the election celebrating the historic nature of Haaland’s victory. … [The only difference is] I did not use a throwaway line about a totem pole as a punch line.”

Publishing the cartoon reflected poor judgment or lack of common sense by the editors. The editors should have been more sensitive to the racist overtones and what was said on social media during the 2026 New Mexico Governor’s election. Throughout the 2026 election process, hostility, and outright racism and slurs were thrown at Deb Haaland on social media, especially by the Republican MAGA crowd, as they degraded Haaland, questioned her intelligence despite her two college degrees, questioned her competency and the positions she has held and her accomplishments. Governor Elect Haaland simply ignored the hate, the racism and slurs as she campaigned as did the overwhelming majority New Mexico voters. Deb Haaland won and made history by becoming first Native American ever elected governor with a 57% to 43% victory over her Republican opponent.

Over the next four years, the Albuquerque Journal and John Trevor no doubt will have more than a few opportunities, and will take them, to criticize Governor Deb Haaland. She has not even been sworn into office, and the Journal should have resisted one last opportunity to be critical of her before she is sworn in on January 1, 2027 which will be a truly historic accomplishment with the election of the first ever Native American as New Mexico Governor.

____________________________

POSTSCRIPT

On Sunday November 15, the Albuquerque Journal in its SPEAKUP! Opinion section published the following comment sent by PETE DINELLI:

“Regarding the editorial cartoon published in the Nov. 9 Sunday Journal. The cartoon was racist, showing a N.M. cowboy with a frown looking down on the first-ever NATIVE AMERICAN WOMAN ELECTED GOVERNOR using the term “totem pole.” The Albuquerque Journal editors know better and should be more sensitive to New Mexico’s diverse culture and apologize.” PD

 

City Agrees To Pay $950,000 Settlement For Personal Injuries To Man Injured In Vehicle Crash With former APD Chief Harold Medina; COMMENTARY: Mayor Tim Keller Failed To Hold Harold Medina Accountable For His Actions Injuring Another With His Failure To Take Appropriate Personnel Disciplinary Action Against Medina

On November 11, it was widely reported by news agencies that the City of Albuquerque and the administration of Mayor Tim Keller agreed to pay $950,000 to settle a personal injury lawsuit filed against the city and former Albuquerque Police Department Chief Harold Medina. The $950,000 settlement was over the 2024 two vehicle crashed where then APD Chief Harold Medina ran a red light fleeing gunfire and crashed into another vehicle leaving the other driver with serious injuries and in critical condition.

Plaintiff Todd Perchert and his wife sued the city in August 2024, seeking compensation for personal injuries and property damage. Perchert was left with titanium plates across his rib cage, deformed bones in his upper arm and stitches in his ear. Perhcert’s vehicle, a classic gold 1966 Ford Mustang, was totaled as was the City issued vehicle to Chief Medina he was driving at the time.

James Tawney, Perchert’s attorney, said this in part in a statement of the  $950,000 settlement:

“No amount of money can take away what happened to Mr. Perchert or undo the physical and emotional toll this crash has taken on him and his family. … The injuries and long recovery left [my client] in significant pain and disrupted nearly every aspect of his life.  [My client] suffered devastating injuries because of the actions of someone entrusted with protecting the public. … No one should be above accountability, regardless of their position.”

Links to relied upon and quoted news sources are here:

https://www.abqjournal.com/news/city-reaches-950000-settlement-with-man-injured-in-crash-with-former-apd-chief/3159900

https://www.koat.com/article/albuquerque-apd-chief-medina-crash-settlement/74392273

https://www.krqe.com/news/albuquerque-metro/city-to-pay-950000-settlement-in-lawsuit-over-crash-involving-former-apd-chief/

https://www.kob.com/new-mexico/city-of-albuquerque-settles-lawsuit-after-crash-involving-former-police-chief/

LAWSUIT FILED

It was on August 26, 2024 that Todd Perchert, the victim of the February 17 car crash caused by APD Police Chief Harold Medina  filed in the 2nd Judicial District Court in Albuquerque a 20 page personal injury lawsuit naming as Defendants the City of Albuquerque and APD Chief Harold Medina. The lawsuit alleges negligence and that “Defendant Harold Medina battered and/or assaulted Todd Perchert by driving at a high rate of speed and violently colliding with Plaintiff’s vehicle.” The civil complaint outlines personal injury damages, alleges violations of the New Mexico Tort Claims Act, and Violations of the New Mexico Civil Rights Act and alleges “Loss of Consortium.” Perchert’s wife, Danielle, was also a named plaintiff.

The Perchert’s claimed Chef Medina violated multiple state laws and department operating procedures when the crash happened. They also alleged the city is responsible because it was negligent in hiring, training and supervising Chief Medina. The 20-page lawsuit also alleged that  Todd Perchert was unable to be gainfully employed as a result of his injuries work and that he “suffered damage to the value and enjoyment of his life” because of his injuries from the crash.

PERSONAL INJURIES OUTLINED

According to news reports, Todd Perchert sought damages for the following personal injuries sustained in the car crash:

  • Broken collarbone and shoulder blade
  • 8 broken ribs (Reconstructed with titanium plates after surgery)
  • Collapsed lung
  • Lacerations to left ear and head
  • Multiple gashes to face
  • Seven-hour surgery
  • Hospitalized with an epidural painkiller and chest tube for nearly a week.

Perchert’s attorney with the law firm of Tawney, Acosta & Chaparro P.C. said this of his client:

“Todd is still experiencing great amounts of pain, due to his extensive injuries, daily pain that he has to deal with. He will tell you that he still feels the metal in his body, dealing with the recovery from the surgeries, continuing treatment. It’s a struggle for him every day to try to continue on with the life that was taken from him before the crash. We’ll let the civil justice system, bring justice to Mr. Perchert.”

The links to quoted and relied upon news sources are here:

Victim of crash involving Albuquerque police chief files lawsuit (koat.com) 

https://www.kob.com/new-mexico/couple-suing-albuquerque-police-and-city-over-chiefs-crash/

https://www.krqe.com/news/albuquerque-metro/albuquerque-police-chief-faces-lawsuit-over-crash/#:~:text=ALBUQUERQUE%2C%20N.M.,his%20classic%20Mustang%20in%20February.

FACTUAL BASIS OF PERSONAL INJURY CLAIM

On February 17, 2024 then  APD Chief Harold Medina and his wife were in an unmarked APD vehicle on their way to participate in a press conference with Mayor Tim Keller when Medina decided to stop and call for APD to clear a homeless encampment. According to news reports, Medina said he and his wife witnessed two men getting into a fight and a gun was pulled and pointed towards Medina and his wife and a shot was fired. Medina said the gunfire caused him to flee through a red light and into the intersection. According to the lawsuit, Medina “hit the gas and tried to speed away from the area” ultimately running a red light and crashing into Perchert’s car in the process. Medina admitted he did not turn on his lights or sirens before speeding off in violation of APD standard operating procedure.

Medina fled from the scene and drove through a red light driving through 3 lanes of traffic and T-Boned a gold-colored classic Ford Mustang driven by Todd Perchert who sustained a broken collarbone, shoulder blade, eight broken ribs, and a collapsed lung.  Both vehicles were totaled.  Perchert was taken to the hospital in critical condition where he underwent 7 hours of surgery for his injuries. A month after the crash, Perchert spoke publicly about what happened and said this:

“I was bleeding while trying to talk with the emergency operators on the phone. I couldn’t breathe, making it difficult to talk.” 

Medina and his wife were unharmed. Medina’s wife was not authorized for a police ride-along. Medina admitted he did not have his lapel camera on and referred the accident to the Superintendent of Police Reform for investigation. Medina passed breath and drug tests after the crash. Medina requested an internal investigation into the crash because he did not have his lapel camera on, which is APD policy violation.

On February 17, 2024, immediately after the car crash, Mayor Tim Keller held a press conference and declared Chief Medina the victim of the accident. Keller said this:

“[Getting the call about the crash was]  one of those types of calls that I dread. … It always starts with, ‘There’s been an altercation with an officer, there’s been a shooting,’ and then I hear it’s the chief. So that is the worst way I ever want to start the day.  … Fortunately, in this case, I quickly learned he was OK.  … [Chief Medina is] arguably the most important person right now in these times in our city. … [The shooting incident is an example of] why we are never quitting when it comes to trying to make our city safer. … But it’s hard. It is extremely hard. It affects everyone, including our chief of police on a Saturday morning. … This is actually him on a Saturday morning, disrupting an altercation, a shooting, trying to do what’s right, trying to make sure that folks are okay after on scene. This is above and beyond what you expect from a chief, and I’m grateful for Harold Medina.

A full week after the crash, Mayor Keller was interviewed and said the driver of the Mustang “happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time … and it was also a beautiful gold Mustang.” 

MEDINA DELARES HIMSELF VICTIM

On Tuesday, February 20, 2024 Chief Medina did a “Chief’s Corner” video briefing which was sent to all APD personnel. He announced that it was a “special edition” of his Chief’s corner to discuss the February 17 car crash with APD personnel. Medina said this in part:

“I was the victim of this traffic accident, and it’s a direct impact of what gun violence is doing to our community. And we need to continue to work at it. I did call out I did submit to a drug test, as any officer would.”

Medina said he was sorry for the man who was injured and wished him “a speedy recovery.” Medina said “We did try to reach out to him and he is not ready to speak to us, and that’s not surprising.”

SURVEILLANCE VIDEO OF ACCIDENT RELEASED

On February 21, 2024, APD released a surveillance video that shows Chief Harold Medina running a red light and crashing into the Ford Mustang seriously injuring the driver of the gold classic Mustang. The surveillance video starts with the usual Saturday morning traffic on East Central. One man walks into the frame heading east while another man crosses Central, heading west. Within seconds they meet on the corner of Central and Alvarado and then you see the two men start fighting. The two men can be seen fighting outside the Tewa Lodge motel, swinging their arms as the scuffle moves down the sidewalk. At the same time, Medina’s APD-issued unmarked truck can be seen inching out into Central and into oncoming traffic, and running a red light.

Medina’s truck drives into oncoming westbound traffic without his emergency equipment lights on nor ostensibly the siren, between two vehicles, one of which appears to stop to avoid a crash. Medina’s truck accelerates through a red light at a high rate of speed and quickly across three lanes of Central and crashes into the classic Mustang headed east. One man who was involved with the fight appeared to watch the crash unfold before running down the sidewalk. Another man rushes to Medina’s truck, appears to look into the truck and immediately rushes off.

The crash resulted in both vehicles doing a half circle turn in a counterclockwise direction. Medina’s truck came to rest against the southeast corner of the intersection with front end and rear end damage including a collapsed rear wheel reflecting an apparent broken axle. The Mustang was struck on the driver’s side with the door ripped opened and it also struck the south curb just east of the intersection and skid east before coming to rest, facing west, in the eastbound lane.

The link to review the surveillance video of the accident is here:

https://www.kob.com/new-mexico/apd-releases-surveillance-video-of-police-chiefs-crash/

RESULTS OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS INVESTIGATIONS

On April 3, 2025, it was reported to the City Council that the APD Crash Review Board voted unanimously to deem Medina’s crash “non-preventable” and therefore Chief Medina was not charged with any traffic violations by APD.

On July 18, 2025 the city announced that the Internal Affairs investigation and disciplinary review of APD Chief Harold Medina actions during the February 17 car crash resulted in two “letters of reprimand” issued to Medina by Superintendent of Police Reform Eric Garcia. Chief Harold Medina was found to have violated APD policy by failing to safely operate his vehicle while on duty and not turning on his lapel camera as required by APD standard operating procedures.

The letters of reprimand were placed in Medina’s personnel file. No other disciplinary action was taken. Mayor Keller did not place Chief Medina on leave nor was his pay suspended and he was not demoted. APD spokesman Gilbert Gallegos said Medina accepted the discipline and signed the letters of reprimand.

NEW MEXICO DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE INVESTGATION

On July 18, 2025  it was announced the Medina vehicle crash was referred to and the Attorney General’s Office to review the Medina car crash “for potential prosecution” and to determine if criminal charges should be brought.  APD announced that the New Mexico Department of Justice decided not to charge Medina with careless driving after investigating the crash.

Deputy Attorney General Greer Staley released a statement and said this:

“Based on our review of all available evidence, we conclude that, although Chief Medina’s actions might satisfy the elements of careless driving, a prosecution would not be warranted because of substantial evidence showing that Chief Medina’s actions were the result of duress. … We decline prosecution and consider this matter closed.”

“CARELESS DRIVING” VERSUS “RECKLESS DRIVING”

The New Mexico Department of Justice evaluated the car crash to determine if it was the result of “careless driving” and declined to investigate if it was the result of “reckless driving”.

It is Section 66-8-114 of the New Mexico Statutes that defines Careless Driving as follows:

  1. Any person operating a vehicle on the highway shall give his full time and entire attention to the operation of the vehicle.
  2. Any person who operates a vehicle in a careless, inattentive or imprudent manner, without due regard for the width, grade, curves, corners, traffic, weather and road conditions and all other attendant circumstances is guilty of a misdemeanor.

https://law.justia.com/codes/new-mexico/chapter-66/article-8/part-2/section-66-8-114/#:~:text=Any%20person%20who%20operates%20a,is%20guilty%20of%20a%20misdemeanor.

It is Section 66-8-113 that defines and prohibits Reckless Driving and it states as follows:

  1. Any person who drives any vehicle carelessly and heedlessly in willful or wanton disregard of the rights or safety of others and without due caution and circumspection and at a speed or in a manner so as to endanger or be likely to endanger any person or property is guilty of reckless driving.
  2. Every person convicted of reckless driving shall be punished, notwithstanding the provisions of Section 31-18-13 NMSA 1978, upon a first conviction by imprisonment for not less than five days nor more than ninety days, or by a fine of not less than twenty-five dollars ($25.00) nor more than one hundred dollars ($100), or both and on a second or subsequent conviction by imprisonment for not less than ten days nor more than six months, or by a fine of not less than fifty dollars ($50.00) nor more than one thousand dollars ($1,000), or both.
  3. Upon conviction of violation of this section, the director may suspend the license or permit to drive and any nonresident operating privilege for not to exceed ninety days.

https://law.justia.com/codes/new-mexico/2018/chapter-66/article-8/section-66-8-113/

APD policy for responding to calls says when officers are responding to a call they must “exercise due regard for the safety of all persons and property.” It adds that they have right of way while responding to a call, but it does not relieve them from the duty to drive with due regard for the safety of all others.

Surveillance video shows Medina cutting in front of another car before accelerating at a high rate of speed through the intersection. Medina could have totally prevented the accident by turning right on Central but instead drove into oncoming traffic driving between 2 other vehicles and the accelerating over 3 lanes of traffic and plowing into Todd Perchert.

INTERNAL AFFAIRS REPORT DISCLOSED

On August 25,2025 it was reported that a report from APD Internal Affairs says APD Chief Harold Medina intentionally did not have his lapel body camera recording on during the car crash he and his wife were involved in on February 17. The Internal Affairs report said that Chief Medina “intentionally and purposefully did not record the interaction of the crash.”  The report goes on to say the chief invoked his Fifth Amendment right to not self-incriminate.

USE OF LAPEL CAMERAS BY ALL LAW ENFORCEMENT MANDATED BY STATE LAW

It was in 2020 that the New Mexico legislature enacted New Mexico Statute § 29-1-18 which mandates the use of body cameras by law enforcement.  The statute reads as follows:

“A.  A law enforcement agency shall require peace officers the agency employs and who routinely interact with the public to wear a body-worn camera while on duty …. . Each law enforcement agency subject to the provisions of this section shall adopt policies and procedures governing the use of body-worn cameras, including:

  1. Requiring activation of a body-worn camera whenever a peace officer is responding to a call for service or at the initiation of any other law enforcement or investigative encounter between a peace officer and a member of the public;
  2. Prohibiting deactivation of a body-worn camera until the conclusion of a law enforcement or investigative encounter;
  3. Requiring that any video recorded by a body-worn camera shall be retained by the law enforcement agency for not less than one hundred twenty days; and
  4. Establishing disciplinary rules for peace officers who … fail to operate a body-worn camera in accordance with law enforcement agency policies .

[B.] Peace officers who fail to comply with the policies and procedures required to be adopted pursuant to Subsection A of this section may be presumed to have acted in bad faith and may be deemed liable for the independent tort of negligent spoliation of evidence or the independent tort of intentional spoliation of evidence.”

There are serious consequences for a law enforcement officer’s failure to abide by the statute. Under the statute, per Section 29-1-18(C), a law enforcement officer “may be presumed to have acted in bad faith and may be deemed liable for the independent tort of negligent spoliation of evidence or the independent tort of intentional spoliation of evidence.”

COMMENTARY AND ANALYSIS

The word’s of Plaintiff’s attorney James Tawney for Todd Perchert discussing the $950,000 settlement are a scathing reminder to the public of Mayor Tim  Keller’s failure to hold former APD Chief Harold Medina personally accountable for his conduct when he said this:

“No amount of money can take away what happened to Mr. Perchert or undo the physical and emotional toll this crash has taken on him and his family. … The injuries and long recovery left [my client] in significant pain and disrupted nearly every aspect of his life.  [My client] suffered devastating injuries because of the actions of someone entrusted with protecting the public. … No one should be above accountability, regardless of their position.”

MEDINA’S VIOLATIONS OF STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES

Medina violated the following APD Standard Operating Procedures:

  • Medina failed to activate his lapel camera in a timely manner.
  • Chief Medina’s wife is not authorized for police ride-along. He involved his wife in a patrol and enforcement action when he decided to report for removal a homeless encampment and it escalated into a felony incident with Medina’s wife being placed in harm’s way.
  • Chief Medina failed to take his wife to a safe, convenient location before he attempted to take action and investigate.
  • Chief Medina did not have his vehicle’s emergency warning equipment engaged when he made the initiate stop to investigate, nor when he took off to flee from the scene.
  • Chief Medina did not drive his vehicle with “due regard for the safety of others.” He drove with reckless disregard for the safety of others and ran a red light driving his vehicle without the vehicle’s emergency equipment on.
  • Chief Medina did not follow Standard Operating Procedures dealing with the investigation of “Crashes Involving Department Issued Vehicles.”

Rank and file police officers would likely be fired, and have been be fired by Chief Medina, for failure to activate their lapel camera in a timely manner and violations of standard operating procedure. Harold Medina however was the Chief of Police and it is clear he was given preferential treatment by his own department and by Mayor Keller who felt  at the time Harold Medina was “arguably the most important person right now in these times in our city.”

MEDINA WAS NOT THE VICTIM

Former APD Chief Harold Medina and Mayor Keller immediately after the accident had the nerve and arrogance to declare Medina the victim of the accident ignoring the real victim and his injuries and the fact that Medina almost killed that victim. Mayor Tim Keller did not hold APD Chief Harold Medina 100% personally responsible nor 100% accountable for the vehicle  crash critically injuring and almost killing a private citizen. However, the citizens of Albuquerque have ultimately been held responsible and have paid the price for Medina’s actions to the tune of $950,000 after Medina has gone off into the sunset and into retirement.

Chief Medina was not criminally charged with reckless driving nor careless driving and could have be terminated “for cause” for the violations of APD’s Standard Operating procedures. Instead, APD Chief Harold Medina was given preferential treatment by APD with a finding that the accident was “non preventable” and a slap on the wrist with two letters of reprimand and a new $100,000 Ford Expedition to drive around in.

FINAL COMMENTARY

The final outcome of this entire case and the failure of Mayor Tim Keller to impose personnel disciplinary action against Harold Medina and failure to hold Medina personally accountable for his conduct will be remembered as the single most egregious case of preferential treatment by Mayor Tim Keller and by APD given to a member of Keller’s executive staff.

 

2026 Veterans Day Dinelli Family Tribute

Each Veterans Day I am compelled to pay tribute to members of my family who have served in our military and who have given so much and sacrificed so much to protect our freedoms and to protect this great country of ours. All these family members were born and lived in New Mexico, two were born in Chacon, New Mexico and the rest born and raised and educated in Albuquerque.

One gave the ultimate sacrifice during time of war.

My father and uncle were first generation born Americans and the sons of Italian immigrants who settled in Albuquerque in the year 1900 to live the American dream. In 1900 Albuquerque had a population of 10,000 and New Mexico did not become a state until 1912.

My father Paul Dinelli and my Uncle Pete Dinelli, for whom I was named after, both served in the US Army during World War II when the United States went to war with Italy, Germany and Japan. My Uncle Pete Dinelli was killed in action when he stepped on a land mine.

My father Paul Dinelli was a disabled American Veteran when he returned to Albuquerque after World War II and was honorably discharged because of a service-connected disability. Years after the war, my father met my mother Rose Fresques at the Alvarado Hotel where she had worked as a Harvey girl. After the couple married, my father went to barber school in Denver, Colorado, returned to Albuquerque and opened “Paul’s Barber Shop” which was located at Third and Lomas.

The Fresques family dates back to the year 1650 in northern New Mexico. My uncles Fred Fresques and Alex Fresques, my mother’s two brothers, also served in World War II. My Uncle Alex Fresques served in England and was in the Air Force.

My uncle Fred Fresques saw extensive action in the US Army infantry during World War II and was awarded 2 Bronze Star medals and a purple heart for his service. The Bronze Star medal is awarded to individuals who, while serving with the Armed Forces of the United States in combat, distinguish themselves by heroism, outstanding achievement, or by meritorious service. The purple heart is awarded for being injured in combat or dying in combat.

My Uncle Fred would never talk to anyone about what he saw. After the war, my Uncle Fred returned to Albuquerque and raised a family in Barelas. Over many years, my Uncle Fred was active in the Barelas Community Center and was a trainer for the “Golden Gloves” competition teaching young adults the sport of boxing.

My father-in-law, George W. Case, who passed away at the age 93, served in the United States Navy during World War II and saw action while serving on a destroyer. My father-in-law George Case was so proud of his service that he wore a World War II Veterans cap every day the last few years of his life. After the war, my father-in-law George Case returned to Albuquerque was married to my mother-in-law Laurel Del Castillo for 50 years, raised a family of 4 girls. George eventually owned a liquor store for a few years and then went on to build, own and operate the Old Town Car wash, which still stands today, and he was in the car wash industry for a number of years.

My nephew Dante Dinelli, the son of my brother Veron and his wife Rosemary, was born and raised in Albuquerque,  and he  joined the service a few years after graduating from Cibola High School. Dante served 20 + years in the US Navy, retired as a Chief Petty Officer and worked in a civilian capacity for the Navy.

My two nephews, Matthew Barnes and Brandon Barnes, the sons of my younger sister Pauline and her husband Marvin, were born and raised in Albuquerque and went to Bosque Prep. Both Mathew and Brandon are in  the United States Marine Corps and both continue to climb the promotion ladder in the Marine Corps.  Both have achieved the rank of Lt. Colonel and both have worked at the pentagon. My nephew Lt. Colonel Brandon Barnes is a graduate of the US Naval Academy. My nephew Lt. Colonel Matthew Barnes graduated from UNM with honors and served a tour in Afghanistan.

To all the wonderful and courageous men and women who have served and continue to serve our country to protect and secure the promise of freedom and the ideals upon which the United States was founded upon, and to those who made the ultimate sacrifice, I thank you for your service to our Country.

Your service and sacrifices to this great country of ours will never be forgotten. God bless you all and God Bless this great country of ours!

Abq. Architecture, Planning And Engineering Firm Awarded $6.2 Million  Contract In Final Days Of Gov. MLG’s Time Left In Office To Create Detailed State Fairgrounds Redevelopment Plan; COMMENTARY: Gov. MLG Clings To Legacy Project Depriving New Gov. Deb Haaland Opportunity To Decide Redevelopment Fate Of State Fair Grounds

On October 9, 2026 the Office of outgoing Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham announced in a news release that the state’s General Services Department has selected the Albuquerque-based architect firm Hartman + Majewski Design Group  to produce a detailed master plan for the New Mexico State Fair Grounds also known as EXPO New Mexico. The contract awarded is valued at more than $6.4 million. Stantec Consulting Services Inc. has already created a general master plan for the site.

Hartman + Majewski was founded in Albuquerque in 2002. The firm describes itself as a “full-service firm specializing in community development”. The group’s past projects include Christus St. Vincent Regional Medical Center, the Albuquerque BioPark’s Asia exhibit, Rio Rancho’s City Hall, Christus St. Vincent Regional Medical Center in Santa Fe, UNM’s Anderson Student Financial Services Center, and the New Mexico State Police District 1 facility. The selection of  Hartman + Majewski Design Group comes seven months after the State Fairgrounds District Board voted 6-1 to approve redevelopment plans for the property’s southwest corner.

The General Services Department has  issued  Request for Proposals (RFP)  for an anchor developer and intends  to make its selection in December. That developer will use the master plan to build Phase One, which will  include affordable housing, parks, an event center and stadium. The state General Services Department will oversee the project development.

The multi-year redevelopment is projected to support upwards of  940 jobs annually over 30 years. The Hartman + Majewski’s detailed plan will provide more specific guidance for the project’s future developer including where to position a proposed sports stadium, a public park and housing. The plan includes designing a park, pedestrian improvements, mixed housing and commercial development, and a stadium.  The entire planning and development process is expected to take up to two years. The Commercial Real Estate Development Association recently released a poll showing that local real estate leaders support the redevelopment project and think it could spur more investment in the International District located directly south if the fairgrounds on Central.

Phase One  is funded with $200 million, which includes money for buying out private properties. The first phase could include housing, a public park, pedestrian improvements, mixed-use commercial spaces and a sports stadium for a professional soccer team. The state is also looking at a potential “phase two” which would add hotels and other features to the site.

State leaders call it an exciting milestone because of what it could do to revitalize Albuquerque’s International District along Central Ave., east of San Pedro. Anna Silva, the Secretary of the New Mexico General Service Department, said this:

“[The contract award marks] a significant step in establishing the planning and design framework necessary to advance the project. The detail master planner basically takes the concept and what we say, what we call program the site, and basically it’s determining where all the pieces are going to be laid out on the site. … The state is also looking at a potential “phase two,” which would add hotels and other features to the site. …  We plan to bring security. We plan to bring development. We plan to bring opportunities for everybody around the area.  So the housing is not going to be pushing people out. we’re going to be enhancing the community,”

Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham said this in a statement:

“We’re making steady progress on the State Fairgrounds, and each step brings us closer to the day when families in the International District can take pride in a revitalized neighborhood that’s safer and provides more economic, recreational and cultural opportunities for all who call the area home. Today’s announcement shows that my administration is committed to enhancing quality of life in the International District and all of Albuquerque.”

Links to quoted or relied upon news sources are here

https://www.krqe.com/home/state-picks-firm-to-create-state-fairgrounds-master-plan/

https://www.kob.com/news/top-news/new-mexico-picks-albuquerque-firm-to-plan-state-fairgrounds-redevelopment/

https://www.abqjournal.com/business/albuquerque-firm-to-create-detailed-state-fairgrounds-redevelopment-plan/3138931

EVOLUTION OF STATE FAIR GROUNDS REDEVELOPMENT EFFORTS

It was on March 21, 2025, in response to Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham’s announcement to redevelop or move the State Fair, also known as Expo New Mexico, the New Mexico legislature passed legislation creating the “State Fairgrounds District.” It is a board that has redevelopment funding authority over the existing State Fair grounds area. The State Fair Commission still remains as the  oversight authority over of the state fair.

The make up of the seven member “State Fairgrounds District” are mandated by statute  to be made up of elected officials except one citizen member appointed by the Governor who is designated by the Governor acting as chairperson. None of the seven members who are elected officials  are subject to approval by the legislature. Voting members of the State Fairgrounds District Governing Board are:

  • Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham, chairperson
  • Albuquerque Mayor Tim Keller
  • Senator Mimi Stewart, Senate President Pro-Tempore, International District, #17
  • State  Representative Janelle Anyanonu whose district the fair grounds is located
  • City Councilor Nichole Rogers whose district the fair grounds is located
  • County Commissioner Adriann Barboa whose district the fair grounds is located
  • Peter Belletto, President, District 6 Neighborhood Coalition

On June 18, 2025 the state General Services Department announced that a $844,433 contract with Stantec Consulting Services Inc. was entered into with the State for Stantec to create a Master Plan  for repurposing the 236-acre tract of land that will make suggestions for the land’s use.

STATE FAIRGROUNDS DISTRICT BOARD VOTES TO SPEND $114 MILLION ON PHASE 1

On March 14, 2026, the State Fairgrounds District Board held its regularly scheduled monthly meeting on the Fairgrounds, with the meeting chaired by Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham. All 7 voting members were present.

The State Fairgrounds District Board voted 6-1 to approve Phase 1 of the Master Plan giving  their approval  for the state to spend $114 million in appropriations from the Legislature once the fiscal year began on July 1. The Phase 1 price tag is upwards of $200 million when combined with previously approved bonds.

Phase 1 includes infrastructure maintenance for the State Fair and to add permanent retail space. Phase 1 concentrates on reshaping and redevelopment of  the 250-acre site and includes upgrading fairground facilities, adding retail and entertainment options and an outdoor stadium.  Phase 1 proposes a mixed-income housing and public park spaces.

According to Stantec Consulting Services Inc  the investment is expected to generate $5.7 million a year in tax earnings which is double what the State Fair currently produces. Phase 1 is expected to create nearly 1,000 jobs.

Representatives with Stantec said the investment covers a wide mix of long‑needed improvements. Stantec said it’s recommending a stadium as an anchor tenant, because it could draw activity year-round.  The funding triggers the start of Phase 1 construction and  includes the following:

  • A new multi-purpose sports stadium.
  • New housing and business space.
  • Park Plaza public spaces.
  • Pedestrian safety improvements.
  • Infrastructure upgrades.
  • New traffic calming and pedestrian safety upgrades on San Pedro.
  • New roads through the fairgrounds site, a park, housing.

The vote included building  an outdoor sports stadium on existing State Fair  property with no plans for replacing and demolition of the aging Tingly Coliseum. It also included a mixed use and  mixed-income housing development on the property located at southwest corner of the Fairgrounds bordered by San Pedro on the West and Central on the South of the New Mexico State Fairgrounds. The Phase 1 development will see the annual State Fair operating as normal while demolition and construction are underway around it.

Voting “YES” to Phase One were Governor Lujan Grisham,  Mayor Tim Keller, City Councilor Nichole Rogers, Senate President Pro Tem Mimi Stewart, D-Albuquerque, state Rep. Janelle Anyanonu, D-Albuquerque, and Peter Belletto, the president of the District 6 Neighborhood Coalition. Bernalillo County Commissioner Adriann Barboa voted “NO” after her motion to defer the vote for one month narrowly failed. Barboa wanted to defer the decision for a month so that the board could first vote on a Community Benefit Agreement (CBA), which sets out requirements for development, such as local hiring.

SEEKING TO REDEVELOP PROPERTY NOT OWNED

The current State Fairgrounds District Board voted to spend upwards of  $200 million on property that is not part of the State Fair grounds and where there are 12 business located.  The Southwest corner property is bordered  by San Pedro on the West and Central on the South and is in fact private property owned by a number of individuals and including limited liability corporations. The state sent out Letters of Interest to Purchase all the properties.

Governor Lujan Grisham and state officials had hoped to have all the property acquired by September 1 so they could break ground on Phase 1. They were being way too optimistic. The State has set aside $22 million to purchase the property and another $15 million for relocation on business, and that just may not be enough, especially if you are dealing with an unwilling seller.

Confidential sources have confirmed that property owners were extremely upset with the state efforts to condemn the properties. Notwithstanding, considerable progress has  been made in acquiring the properties at fair market value but those acquisitions and associated purchase prices for the land have yet to be announced by the state.

MASTER PLAN PRESENTATION BY STANTEC

On March 14, 2026, after over three months of community input and surveys conducted, Stantec Consulting Services held a public meeting and made a presentation on the Master Plan which included a presentation on Phase 1 of the Master Plan.

“Recommendations highlights include the State Fair remaining on the Fairgrounds, with investment in infrastructure and facilities upgrades, as well as an outdoor sports stadium as a strong economic anchor, activating the Fairgrounds and its edges with a walkable, mixed-use core, including housing and commercial activity.

Based on community feedback and discussion with Expo NM staff, the Fairgrounds would be reimagined from a seasonal venue into a place where residents and visitors can meet, dine, shop, stay, recreate, learn, live, and work through-out the year. Mixed-use environments would be programmed even on non-event days, centering housing, community venues, parks, and workplaces that could significantly expand Gross Receipts Tax (GRT) generation, a portion of which is utilized to unlock bonding for future development on the Fairgrounds.

Critical to Phase 1 recommendations are that the Fairgrounds are integrated into the surrounding neighborhoods by connected streets, parks, activated edges and pedestrian improvements.”

The Stantec report found that the cost of relocating the fair would be $1.1 Billion to $1.970 Billion for relocation and redevelopment. ($1.1 billion along with another $870 million for development. )

The link to review Stantec’s March 14 Master Plan presentation is here:

Click to access NMSFG_Draft-Recommendations_Public-Meeting-3.pdf

COMMENTARY AND ANALYSIS

On January 1, 2027, Governor Elect Deb Haaland will officially be sworn into office replacing Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham.  All seven members of the  State Fairgrounds District Governing Board are mandated by statute to be elected officials except a citizen member appointed by the Governor who is the chairperson on the board. Govenor Haaland will become the new chair and she could decide to replace the appointed citizen. She could decide not to convene the board ever again, decide to replace the citizen board member even seek to abolish the board.

The entire seven member State Fair Commission appointed by Governor Lujan Grisham will likely be replaced by Governor Haaland as commission terms end. Then there is the fact that State Fair Manager Dan Morning could also be replaced by Governor Haaland. Dan Mourning has been the manager of the New Mexico State Fair for upwards of 15 years. He took over the role of Sate Fair Manager when he was appointed by then Republican Susana Martinez. By all accounts, Morning has done a respectable job and has significantly influenced the fair’s environment and operations. It is well known that Morning is no fan of moving the State Fair Grounds.

It is downright pathetic that outgoing Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham would award a $6.2 Million contract to create a detailed State Fairgrounds Redevelopment Plan less than 90 days before she leaves office. It is an apparent effort by her to cling to a legacy project depriving her successor Governor Deb Haaland any room to change course on design or priorities.  Governor Lujan Grisham could easily go  down as the Governor who destroyed the State Fair for the sake of her ego.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING NOT HIGHEST AND BEST USE OF FAIRGROUNDS

At least $30 million of the Phase 1 monies is dedicated specifically for affordable housing and other types of income level housing. The blunt reality is that $30 million will not  go very far to build affordable housing. The term affordable housing is a false narrative. When the term “affordable housing” is used by elected officials, investors and developers, what they mean is “subsidized government housing.”  Construction costs are consistent when it comes to building a new housing and affordable housinfg.  According to the Homebuilders Digest, construction costs covering everything from materials to the actual construction average between $175 to $225 per square foot. To build a 750 square foot housing unit would therefore carry a cost of $131,000 to $168,750.

What the State Fair District Board did not take into account nor discuss is that the years 2024, 2025, 2026 were banners years for state appropriations to expand homeless and affordable housing projects in the City, including in the International District. During the 2024 and the 2025 legislative sessions, the New Mexico Legislature dedicated more than $300 million to various housing-related measures at different agencies, including revolving loans for builders, down-payment assistance and anti-homelessness programs.  The Legislature specifically earmarked $110 million in the 2025  year’s budget of the $10.8 billion budget for affordable housing and homelessness assistance programs.

During the 2026 legislative session, the New Mexico legislature appropriated $175 million for statewide housing and homelessness initiatives with the lion’s share going to Albuquerque. The 2025 New Mexico Legislature approved upwards of  $140 million for housing programs during the legislative session with $83 Million of the $140 Million is earmarked for  projects in the Albuquerque area for housing and the unhoused.

PARK AREA ACCESED FROM CENTRAL WILL LIKELY BE MAGNET FOR CRIME AND UNHOUSED

Phase 1 places a major emphasis and dedicates a large portion of the State Fair property to park area with access from Central. The reality of the city’s homeless crisis is that parks are notoriously magnets for crime and the unhoused. At this point, the State Fairgrounds, does not have a crime problem with the New Mexico State Police having primary law enforcement responsibility to calls for service. The lack of crime on the state fair property will no doubt change with a park and access from Central.

Area resident Dave Kailer was absolutely correct when he was questioned whether a proposed park could thrive in the area and he said this:

“You know what is going to happen to that park if you put it in the war zone? It will turn into a homeless park, let’s face it. … I don’t want to be ugly about it or negative about it. I’m just being realistic.”

History tends to repeat itself over and over again especially when it comes to the homeless crisis and parks in Albuquerque. The State Fair District Board might as well dedicate any park on State Fair grounds property with public access from Central as Coronado Park 2 in remembrance to Coronado Park which was closed by the city as a result of more than 125 unsheltered people taking over the park to camp and it becoming a hot bed for narcotic usage, trafficking illicit drugs and violent crime, including homicides and rapes.

MISPLACED REDEVLOPMENT GOALS

Five out of the current seven State Fair District Board members are elected officials of the International District with the President of the District 6 Coalition of Neighborhoods representing the  International District. It apparent that  Governor Lujan Grisham’s appointed State Fair District Board were strictly dedicated to reviving and benefiting the International District. Governor Lujan Grisham and the other six members of the State Fair District  Board  essentially  ignored  the needs and safety concerns of neighborhoods and businesses to the West, North and East of the Fairgrounds as well as the state wide support for the State Fair remaining where it is.

Outgoing Governor Lujan Grisham  and her appointed State Fair District Board  are using  State Fair property to solve all the crime, economic problems and lack of affordable housing of the International District.  Until you reduce crime and homeless on Central itself and in the International District itself, redevelopment of the State Fair property to benefit the International District will fail.

The International District, which is bordered by Central South of the State Fairgrounds has had for decades some of the highest violent crime, property crime and drug offense rates, so much so that it was at one time referred to as the WAR ZONE until it was officially renamed the International District, but the renaming had no impact on the trajectory of the area.  The International District continues to be plagued by high crime rates and  now has become a magnet for the homeless with encampments constantly popping up and cleaned up by the city only to pop up again.

Crime and the unhoused is what is destroying  private investment, job growth and small business development within  in the International District. After all the millions are spent to redevelop the fairgrounds, to improve infrastructure and traffic flow, building a park, adding public spaces and allowing businesses and low-income housing, the problems of high crime rates and the unhoused will remain the same in the International District because they have never been solved for decades. No businesses will want to relocate to the State Fair grounds after it is developed into commercial property, and it will become a magnet for crime and for the homeless, especially with parks.

CONCLUSION

On day one of assuming office, Governor Deb Haaland will have to decide sooner than later exactly what to do with the State Fairgrounds District Governing Board, replacing members of the State Fair Commission where she can and perhaps finding a new State Fair Manager. Governor Haaland should also decide if she wants to suspend or decide what can be done with the $6.4 million contract awarded for to create a detailed State Fairgrounds Redevelopment Plan by Governor Lujan Grisham in the wanning days of her administration.

Expo New Mexico can be revitalized into an Entertainment and Commercial Hub  that could revitalize the entire SE Heights and surrounding area with creation of all new commercial property areas leased by the State Fair for shops, restaurants, theaters and entertainment venues that would also be used for operations of the annual State Fair and during the State Fair itself. The aging Tingly Coliseum should be demolished and a new multipurpose, state of the art venue should be built to replace it.

There should be no affordable housing and no other housing on the property. No portion of the State Fair acreage should be sold to any developer. The existing walls along San Pedro, Lomas and Louisiana should remain intact for security reasons but develop larger entrances. Efforts to revitalize adjoining neighborhoods should only be undertaken by private developers perhaps with state and city development and tax incentives.

The link to a related, previous article is here:

State Fairgrounds District Board Votes To Spend $114 Million On State Fair Grounds Redevelopment; Includes Building Outdoor Sports Stadium; Housing And Redevelopment Included On Private Property Not Yet Acquired; No Decision Made On Moving Fairgrounds With Cost Of $1.1 Billion To $1.97 Billion To Move